Official Doctor Who Thread

Started by The Nuul181 pages

Matt is the 2nd best to play the Doctor. I didnt like Christopher Eccleston at all.

To you yes, to me he isn't second best. 😛

I loved Chris!

I'll be honest, I kind of tend to forget that first season existed. I don't know why, but he didn't really make much of an impression on me as the Doctor.

... you suck!

I liked Eccleston. Not as much as Matt or Tennant, but I thought he was good.

It IS in the rules that dissing Eccleston is a bannable offence, yeah?

Sure, I think I read that somewhere...
(Note to self...)

I think Eccleston was a good doctor but got the worste storylines, aliens that fart as a threat...seriously? Slythene were the worste

Originally posted by Ushgarak
It IS in the rules that dissing Eccleston is a bannable offence, yeah?

Ok, ban yourself....

I liked Eccleston too, seeing as it was Nine that dragged me into Doctor Who and made me a fan. I'm still working on the whole 'seeing the prior eight Doctors' thing, aside from 'Genesis of the Daleks.'

Originally posted by Ushgarak
It IS in the rules that dissing Eccleston is a bannable offence, yeah?
Originally posted by The Nuul
Ok, ban yourself....

WTF?

😕

For what it's worth, while Eccleston was my first Doctor and was fantastic, in my opinion Tennant surpassed him in every single way. Smith... sits somewhere in the middle, not as brilliant as Tennant but more fun to watch than Eccleston.

I'm pretty sure Ten will forever be my Doctor, though.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
... you suck!

I liked him a lot as the Doctor, he just...didn't really stand out as much to me. I don't know why. Part of it might have been how I pretty much saw every episode of his in about a week, and you didn't even show me all of them, so they sort of all blended together.

So, I suppose I can ultimately blame you for that fact, so hah!

Chris rules!!!

Just seen the final two part story and it was not so much of a big bang more like a whimper, looks like the recession has hit the Dr Who budget.

Or was it a deliberate low key story? After all the big slam bang thank you mam stories of the past, any how it was alright.

I am getting fed up with dragging it out storylines of the big finals, please no more.

Over all the series was not bad and Matt Smith pulled it off. As for Karen Gillan, I just wish she stopped doing the open wide eyeballs routine which for me is a pain, and as for Arthur Darvill, fair so far.

Chris was ok but he just cant stand up to Tennant who really made me a dr who fan so I found even beetter dotors like Mcgann so Ecclestone and Smith are quite far down the list

Originally posted by The Nuul
WTF?

😕

Why are you WTFing?

Originally posted by steverules_2
Why are you WTFing?

Because I cannot read and just posted crap that didnt make any sense.

You certainly do sly