The Nooooooo scene [Merged]

O wow he crushed a couple droids i mean come on i would of loved to see him thowing clone troopers around the room if their were any, its an ok scene but i just thougt it was cheesy.

Yes, it was cheesy, and it was supposed to be. Star Wars in general is pretty cheesy if you think about it. The NOOOO just made it seem that Vader's humanity was completely gone, although we know it is restored.

There is a lot of cheesy scenes in Star Wars, but his one was totally out of place.

I would of prefered him yelling out ARGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH in a angrey tone plus hayden looked like he was about to fall over in that suit.

Well think about it, he was just put in the suit so it's awkward for Vader. He has yet to get used to it. I'm sure you'd stumble too.

Originally posted by Jedi_KnightAlly
Yeah, i felt this just wasn't darth vader, it just wasn't done right.

I wouldn't say it ruined the movie though, but i thought oh right at it.

its still anakin he just has a suit on.. hes not as old and bitter as in the OT it makes perfect sense that he is upset, and perfect sense he cant walk great seeing as he has to fake legs hes never used before.

Originally posted by Jedi_KnightAlly
Did anyone else think this was just not darth vader?

The point when Vader asks sidious, What happened to padme? And sidious replys... You killed her.

He then does a ridiculous "NOOOOOOOOOO"

That was so badly done.

Actually no I don't think it was ridiculous or cheesy. This scene is very reminiscence to Frankestein. The creature is incredible pain and releases all his pain at once. The scene that I found to be cheesy was when Obi says to Anakin "I love you"

I thought Jedi's weren't allowed to love? 😛

It was supposed to be like his last shred of humanity leaving him...even though he screwed up...he still had the hope that he had saved Padme..also notice how much Palp's is eating up Vader's pain... I wasn't bothered by the "Nooooo..." so much as I was by the lack of damage in the room. From all the spoilers and stuff, I thought it was going to be more electric...more dynamic..

So frankeinstein-ish, I don't like it either.

I want to know why Sidious would tell him that. Did he think if he found out his wife died the way he saw in his dream and his inability to help her would make him leave his master? Or just to cut off all ties to anything resembling family for Vader.

I had no porblem with him saying no, but JEJ could have put more into it. As far as the frankenstien connection, remember the guy just got 2 new legs and put on about 80 pounds.

Revenge of the Sith

I was so disappointed! Not since Return of the Jedi have I been so disappointed. Look I hold Star Wars very sacred...and ROTJ is sacred in parts but by judging from my screen name you might have guessed that I'm not a big ewok fan.

Anyway back to the issue at hand. I agree with most of the posts here. There was way too much lightsaber action which took away the "awe" factor when they were limited in the other installments.
Usually at the end.
Bad things about ROTS...
1. I think the mitichlorian theory and the possibility that Anakin is possibly Palp's son is just plain ubsurd. The prophecy was untrue.
2.The Qui-Gon factor was completely unexplained. No voice over. 3.Grevious hacking like a sickened person but yet strong enough to fight. The window blast scene in the Grevious chamber when Gen. Grev escapes ( no one dies or gets sucked out).
4. The wookies werent in it enough.
5. Not enough time to get really attached to anyone character it moved at an incredibly fast pace.
6. Darth Vader is in the movie on the gurney in full amor and cape?...please. And don't get me started on the "lost the will to live line" and The "Noooooooo" line.

But after all this bitching I thought the worst scene out of all the scenes and should have been cut, was that awful scene of Anakin slaying children. (Twice) ...Bad just purely a bad scene. Overall I'd say yeah...disappointed but hell its Star Wars.

I loved the yoda fight scene and the opening battle with the crash ending...other than that...I'll stick with my fave of all time Empire Strikes Back!

Peace and may the force be with you.

This isnt the review thread.

Oops..........but thanks for pointing out my shortcomings Astro.

It would have been better if it was just implied she'd lost the will to live... it is a bad line.

The "Nooo!" should have been more of an "Arrgh".

Originally posted by DeVi| D0do
The "Nooo!" should have been more of an "Arrgh".

Oooh, I like that. Just angry scream would have been perfect.

To hear him say "Where is Padme?"

was at first a little much for me...😖

But I genuinely felt his pain when he cried out, come on guys, he's lost everything, and now he's this deformed creature forever bound in the shrouds of his own darkness...He's torn to pieces, figuratively, AND literally. ANd now he's lost the person he did all this for...

Originally posted by Ewoksaredumb

Anyway back to the issue at hand. I agree with most of the posts here. There was way too much lightsaber action which took away the "awe" factor when they were limited in the other installments.
Usually at the end.
Bad things about ROTS...
1. I think the mitichlorian theory and the possibility that Anakin is possibly Palp's son is just plain ubsurd. The prophecy was untrue.
2.The Qui-Gon factor was completely unexplained. No voice over. 3.Grevious hacking like a sickened person but yet strong enough to fight. The window blast scene in the Grevious chamber when Gen. Grev escapes ( no one dies or gets sucked out).
4. The wookies werent in it enough.
5. Not enough time to get really attached to anyone character it moved at an incredibly fast pace.
6. Darth Vader is in the movie on the gurney in full amor and cape?...please. And don't get me started on the "lost the will to live line" and The "Noooooooo" line.

But after all this bitching I thought the worst scene out of all the scenes and should have been cut, was that awful scene of Anakin slaying children. (Twice) ...Bad just purely a bad scene.

omg... OK!

1. Anikan does fullfill the profecy in ROTJ. The profecy is true according to creator George Lucas. Your wrong.
2. Qui-gon could communicate through the force, he was the first to learn. He can't appear in spirit however. You don't get that?
3. No one dies or gets sucked out because there's 2 people in the room, Anikan and Obi, they hang on to a control panel, the emergency systems kick in.
4. what do you want, revenge of the wookies? Maby we should shape the movie round you eh? It's not about the wookies, if you look at it in the film critique sense, they were just a plot device to get yoda on his own.
5. There were 3 movies to get attached to em. If you hadn't done it by now... well... what can I say.
6. Believe it or not, people can die from emotional strain, weird but true. So in a sci-fi film, I guess it's believable that the emotional strain plus getting force choked and 'forcing' out 2 twins is enough to make you heel over.

The "noooooo" line, look people... who are we to say it's not what vader, or a turning anikan would do... I guess we know better than the creator of vader eh. IT'S THE WAY IT'S MEANT TO BE!?!?!! I don't think it's meant to be, 'cool', and I don't think at the time, he'd care how he'd say it. aaargh being better than no? You lose everyone you loved and see if you don't scream noooo like a little sissy. JEJ would of been told to do it the same way as Haydens voice over.

I agree, it had it's bad parts. I guess I just really enjoyed it cos I went in knowing there'd be screw ups, and that Lucas would stuff it up, then I came out pleasently suprised!

The nooooo is fine by me.

Dunno about you guys, but I got chills down my spine when the Vader mask went on and he breathed through it for the first time.

Originally posted by Ewoksaredumb
[B]

Bad things about ROTS...
1. I think the mitichlorian theory and the possibility that Anakin is possibly Palp's son is just plain ubsurd. The prophecy was untrue.

2.The Qui-Gon factor was completely unexplained. No voice over.
[quote]
I agree with you here...I was at least expecting a phantom of qui gon to appear...or yeah even a voice over...

[quote]3.Grevious hacking like a sickened person but yet strong enough to fight. The window blast scene in the Grevious chamber when Gen. Grev escapes ( no one dies or gets sucked out).

4. The wookies werent in it enough.

5. Not enough time to get really attached to anyone character it moved at an incredibly fast pace.

6. Darth Vader is in the movie on the gurney in full amor and cape?...please. And don't get me started on the "lost the will to live line" and The "Noooooooo" line.

*throws in two cents*