The Nooooooo scene [Merged]

Started by Stunrun10 pages

Re: Darth Vader's NOOOO!

Originally posted by lau_timmy
If he just cried AAAAAAA or UHHHH in pain it would of made more sense
but NOOOOOOOOOOOO is too cheesy. That ruined the whole drama and almost like a joke.

I loved it😎 im still too caught up in the movie to criticize it

Just because Anakin puts the Darth Vader Armour on doesn't mean that he's Darth Vader the real Vader that we know and love comes much later. So the scene where he screams NOOOOOOOOO... is Anakin, not Vader... even though technically during that scene he had been given that sith name of Vader it's really not Vader just the begininng of Vader!

awful lineeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

I prefer...You promised me she would live...Unlimited Power!

It's not great but it didn't bother me.

theyshould re-record it to sound better for the DVD release....

i like that idea biker scout, youd think that would cross his mind

Originally posted by ickeris2003
at first it did bother me but when i saw it for the 2nd time it did make sense because its still anakin and hes not fully evil yet.
Exactly. It's basically 'Hayden Anakin' under there, 20 years later in Ep IV, I'm sure he's hardened up quite a bit.

But could you really even pictire Hayden saying 'No' like that?

I still say it should have been an 'Aaaarrrgh!' with Vader destroying the room with his rage.

Originally posted by DeVi| D0do
But could you really even pictire Hayden saying 'No' like that?
Actually, yeah 😬

It was awful and people laughed in the cinema.

Remember when Empire Strikes Back was re released in theatres in the late 90s? Lucas added a scream to luke falling into the abyss after hs confrontation with his Father. He took that scream back out again for the DVD I notice. I'm hoping he does a similar "repair" or edit on that "Noooooo..." scene for when it comes out on DVD.

well the NOOOOO parody has now hit song format (read: edited existing song)

http://unitedstatesofno.ytmnd.com/

http://darthno.ytmnd.com/

Originally posted by HateWork
well the NOOOOO parody has now hit song format (read: edited existing song)

http://unitedstatesofno.ytmnd.com/

hilarious!
😂

but whats the big problem??😬 i LOVE that line! Vader came from the 70's, so it just sounded right imo✅ nothing wrong with a lil cheese😎

Those sites are quality, if a little annoying after a while lmao!! I have an explanation as to why the nooooooooo was done like that. For one thing we haven't seen Vader really expressing emotion before so it seems out of place. But we must remember that although he's Vader and has turned to the darkside, his love for Padme remains because love is ultimately more powerful than the darkside e.g. Vader turns back to the lightside in ROTJ because of the love for his son. So he still loves Padme and has just found out he killed her. However he's 'more machine than man' now so the way he will express his emotion will be rather mechanical and that's why the nooooo seems wierd. At first it seemed cheesy which it is but then I watched it again and realised it's necessary to show that he is mostly machine. Steven Hawking for example has to use an electronic voicebox to speak and his words don't sound that emotional obviously because they're created by a machine. It doesn't mean he isn't feeling the emotion inside. The same goes for Vader, he feels this sadness inside after finding out his wife is dead but the only way he can express it is in a mechanical fashion (hence the noooooo) which is so tragic as he is trapped in this black prison for the rest of his life (well until ROTJ). So I think the nooooooooooo is fine as it portrays the mixture of human emotion in a mechanical way. The movement here as well also is very mechanical as he's obviously not going to cover his face as he has a helmet on, he can't fall to his knees as he's just adapting to these robotic legs so the only way he can express himself is with his arms to side of him and his head slightly tilted up almost like he's asking the force why have you let this happen to me?! So yeh anyone who doesn't like the nooooooo only doesn't like it because they don't understand it but I think it makes perfect sense and truly shows how Anakin/Vader is 'more machine than man now'!

Originally posted by benskywalker88
Those sites are quality, if a little annoying after a while lmao!! I have an explanation as to why the nooooooooo was done like that. For one thing we haven't seen Vader really expressing emotion before so it seems out of place. But we must remember that although he's Vader and has turned to the darkside, his love for Padme remains because love is ultimately more powerful than the darkside e.g. Vader turns back to the lightside in ROTJ because of the love for his son. So he still loves Padme and has just found out he killed her. However he's 'more machine than man' now so the way he will express his emotion will be rather mechanical and that's why the nooooo seems wierd. At first it seemed cheesy which it is but then I watched it again and realised it's necessary to show that he is mostly machine. Steven Hawking for example has to use an electronic voicebox to speak and his words don't sound that emotional obviously because they're created by a machine. It doesn't mean he isn't feeling the emotion inside. The same goes for Vader, he feels this sadness inside after finding out his wife is dead but the only way he can express it is in a mechanical fashion (hence the noooooo) which is so tragic as he is trapped in this black prison for the rest of his life (well until ROTJ). So I think the nooooooooooo is fine as it portrays the mixture of human emotion in a mechanical way. The movement here as well also is very mechanical as he's obviously not going to cover his face as he has a helmet on, he can't fall to his knees as he's just adapting to these robotic legs so the only way he can express himself is with his arms to side of him and his head slightly tilted up almost like he's asking the force why have you let this happen to me?! So yeh anyone who doesn't like the nooooooo only doesn't like it because they don't understand it but I think it makes perfect sense and truly shows how Anakin/Vader is 'more machine than man now'!
Well, said, never really thought of it that way.

it was ok for me. though the silent drop-to-your-knees act would've done as good. a chance to see a vulnerable darth vader is a rare occurence.

People do stupid things in real life you dont understand, and they do it in the movies. Your not gonna like everything... not even in a movie.

Ben Skywalker is right. The key word is understanding. People just dont do that nowadays. Always critisizing before speaking.

You also have to remember that this all happened a long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away.

I've seen it the once, and would have to see it again. But the first viewing reminded me of the Simpsons, because they done that several times in a humours fashion. So the first viewing it seemed a little off, but seeing it again it may look different.

I thought it was hilarious when Vader busted out that "NOOOOOOOOOO" scene truly a classic 😆

Hey every1, here's a little song I remixed using Vader's nooooooooooo!!! DJ Vader strikes back 😛!!

h**p://w**.putfile.com/media.php?n=nooooo_0002