The Nooooooo scene [Merged]

when that sceen happened me and my 4 other friend that went too see it started cracking up. when the end credits started it was dead silent in the theater and i just screamed NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!! and i sound almost exactly like James earl jones and everyone in the theater started busting out laughing.

lol

I didn't quite like this scene, thought it was gonna be better
I kinda got the impression that it was Homer Simpson screaming NOOOOOOOOO!!

Oustanding! 😂

Originally posted by Jedi_KnightAlly
Did anyone else think this was just not darth vader?

The point when Vader asks sidious, What happened to padme? And sidious replys... You killed her.

He then does a ridiculous "NOOOOOOOOOO"

That was so badly done.

I agree.
It was funny in a ridiculous way and yet made everyone go "WTH"

Originally posted by Ushgarak
As queeq says, it really wasn't problematic enough to bother me any.

Way more bothered by, for example, shoe-horning Qui-Gon in like that with no decent explanation.

oh, it didnt ruin the film for me at all. i just wish that part was done better.

and yes, quigon's deletion was so very sad. wtf was GL thinking? he KNEW we all were dying to see it, and cut it. what a dicky thing to do

The scene as written in the script is pretty lame, I didn't have to see that. But I would have liked a decent explanation about the disappearing thing. Now one has to sit in the desert for 20 years to learn it. PLUS how is it that Anakin can suddenly do the reappearing thing all of a sudden. Who taught him?

No on those counts, GL really screwed up.

Also ILM f-ed up the shot when they replaced Vader's arms. When he "busts out" the movement and blending into the live action sucks. His arms pull up and then jerk forward like he pulled them down from were they were by his head. Plus...in the wide shot after he stumbles out...you can see where his arms were clamped up high...bad job ILM...bad job.

I agree with the change but ffs do it right.

haha that part was so funny! my friend and i laughed about that so much...he seemed so out of character when he did that

Originally posted by Ben-Kenobi
I dont care about that scene it made vader seem like a freaking pansey, I swear after that scene i barely have any respect for Darth Vader

VADER is a pansy?

They should just have replaced the "Noooooooooooooooooooooo" with the Wilhelm scream. ROTS is the only Lucas effort not to have it and it would have been perfect in that scene.

Vader moved like Frankenstein when he removed the shackles

Originally posted by Whisper
They should just have replaced the "Noooooooooooooooooooooo" with the Wilhelm scream. ROTS is the only Lucas effort not to have it and it would have been perfect in that scene.

Hey chief...the Wilhelm was in the opening space battle. One of the clone troopers cried out on a capital ship when it got hit...

😄

doesnt vadars mask muffle and manipulate anakins real voce? so maybe it goes in sounding like a lion, but comes out sounding like bad writing.

Originally posted by Darth_Vader05
People this is when Darth Vader is still human he isnt fully evil until A New Hope come on people.

He was evil enough to kill younglings. I agree that that part was just off. One of my least favorite scenes of the movie.

I didn't see anything wrong with it. You're being too critical.

Originally posted by Reborn Again
I didn't see anything wrong with it. You're being too critical.

Originally posted by Reborn Again
I didn't see anything wrong with it. You're being too critical.

Was I the only person who flashed James T. Kirk yelling "Khaaaaaaaaaan" in Star Trek 2?? 🙂

The move off of the table was VERY Frankenstein. All that was needed was Palatine yelling "He's alive!"

I think that james earl jones couldn't deliver a line liek that any better way. It's jsut the way he talks...
Perhaps he could have just yelled like "ARRHHHHH"?

I can't believe that post. Hours before Anakin was dying and some people want him to jump of the table and start throwing punches like Oscar the la Hoya and destroying things like he do when he was healthy. This guy is almost dead and is recovering from deadly injuries. Did you see his face when the mask go over. It has blood. This guy was almost dead. And the most important thing is Star Wars is the baby of George Lucas. Everyone criticise, but nobody has created a movie. Criticize is simple. Create something is difficult. I believe that the scene was good because it shows the pain and the inability that Vader has at that moment to be physically powerful.