Meh. NJO Luke is the Nihilus of the Jedi side of Versus, I swear. Only, NJO Luke is much more fallible than people give him credit for being. He's human, not god.
ROTS Anakin isn't the sharpest pencil in the drawer, and him clashing against Revan is the end of Skywalker. I don't care how much you like Annie or ROTS, he doesn't have the control and the wisdom to outwit Obi-Wan, much less the ancient Sith.
Now, NJO Luke may be damn good, but the Exile has the potential to murder three Jedi masters and kills Sion, Nihilus, and Kreia. And he's -weaker- than Revan. So the Exile could at least engage Luke until Revan coudl hand Skywalker his presuit ass and go on to double team Luke. The Exile might even die, or Luke could possibly win. (Never fair to rule out a victory considering some rather stunning victories in SW universe) but the odds are against teh Skywalkers.
Well Luke in the NJO is basiclly a 48 year old by TUF version of Anakin. A weaker version of course, but still just slightly. On the force.net in the article on midi-clorians, I think they said something about them mainly, like 80 percent, being controlled by the father. I know this isn't correct because Han isn't force sensitive, but produces three powerful children. Still, according to this theory, Luke should be about 80 percent as powerful as Anakin could have become with the same training that they each got. Lots of people would say that Luke didn't get very good training, but I think he got great training. He beat Vader,(to a degree) the vision of Vader, confronted the Emperor, Jorus C'baoth(this is a very important fight, I will go into detail as to why it is so important ina minute), Shimera (the most powerful out of a species of warriors, basicly a DLOS, but scaled down a little), Emperor Reborn(probably learned a thing or two from him), Exar Kun( he did actually help in this, not just sit there like Revan33 says), hundreds of Reborn people( the one's from Jedi Academy. I know it only shows Jaden fighting them, but Luke has to have fought a lot also, probably more then Jaden did. And I also know that they are basicaly regular people swing lightsabers around. Still has to count for something though.), Dathomir Witches( these people can be pretty powerful in groups and brought down the Chu'thor. For those who don't know what the Chu'thor is, it was a mobile Jedi Temple. Yoda taught some people on it for a while. It dosen't make much sense that some witches could bring down a ship full of Jedi, but they did somehow, there was probably not very many Jedi onit at the time and there was a probably a few hundred witches. I changed my mind, I'm not going to try and make sense of it.), Hethir(guy who helped in anpther Empire Reborn group in the crappiest SW book ever, the Crystal Star. Please dont read that book, its for your own good. IT is a crappy book.), Brakiss(a falled student.) Keuller(another failed stuydent.) the Jennsarri(I dont think that I spelled it right. They were pretty powerful and had lightsabers and all the stuff.)
He also fought a lot of other force users, but I won't name them right now. Wait, there is another I will name, Luuke. Imagine fighting yourself to the death. It would be very difficult and you would need some outside interference to win, unless you were slightly stronger. Luke was slighty stronger and beat himself. This would be some intense fighting. You would also learn a ton.
And the reason that I said that Joruus is important is because the original, Jorus, became a Jedi Knight in only four lears. This is how long it took Luke and this guy didn't even have Skywalker blood. This guy also became a very powerful Jedi Master like ten years after that.
IO haven't even named every force user that Luke fought, but that is enough to show he is very experinced. Luke and Anakin win.
Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Exar Kun( he did actually help in this, not just sit there like Revan33 says)
He might have but it doesn't say it in the book. It is extremely vague on that point so I'll admit there's a possibility he helped.
As for my two cents, NJO Luke would kill the Exile, Lord Revan would kill Anakin, then Luke and Revan would fight with Revan winning.