Anakin in ROTS is way better then in AOTC, but he is still lacking control and willpower, he doesn't think about what he does, and he just rushes into everything. Exile would have much more experience then Ani, I think he is physically stronger, and Anakin couldnt defeat 1 average jedi master(obi wan). Now, i know that he helped killing Mace, but Palpy actually did most of the work, storming him, Ani just choped his arm off, and thats not such an accomplishment, since Mace completely trusted the boy. And Dooku could never compare to Sion or Kreia. So Exile beats Anakin, and Revan could at least hold Luke off(in my oppinion he would make sliced deep fried bacon out of Luke. Luke = pussy) untill Exile joins. Now about Luke having great training. All those people he beat, thats not actually training, because he cannot learn any new techniques, new forms, new powers...So basicly, he knows nothing, because normally jedi are trained from youth(5 years or somehting like that) and he was trained from 20(i think). And he was trained not more tehn a month overal. He is the only jedi who was trained a month i think. He only beat Vader because he gave in to dark side for a minute or two, and Vader couldnt hold off his mad swinging, which as more similar to baseball then to saber dueling. He couldnt possibly find so much knowledge as Revan did, learn so many powers, and master them. He didnt get as much experience as Revan, and killing that reborn scum is nothing. Being killed by one is a shame for the jedi.
I hate NJO Luke he's to powerful in those books, its like he can not be defeated... Why he ever became the most powerful Jedi ever is really beyond me, he does not have the potential or the masters to teach him everything he needs.
Both the Exile and Revan trained from child birth.. Anakin would get owned by either of them, he's good but he does not have the skill the mastery of the force or the power to match them. NJO Luke even if he is god he still won't stand a chance against those two together.
Originally posted by Kun-ni Habeo
but luke can kill one of them and then assist anakin defeating the other
So let me get this straight, you honestly think that a guy who has 20 years and 1 month of training at most can defeat either Revan or the Exile who both at least had 20 something probably 30 years of training both have had great destiny's who both defeated great and powerful Sith lords faster then one of them can defeat Anakin?
Bullshit.
The Exile will walk over Anakin, take him out kill him end his life once and for all and then its just him and Revan against God... Luke will lose
Anakin holds off Revan? My ass he will. The fight would go like this
Anakin walking up to Revan his blade behind his back as he does sometimes. Revan just stabs forward throws a second lightsaber cutting Anakin from the front and back killing him. Seriously Anakin stands no chance agianst the Exile or Revan and he sure as hell can't hold any of them off longer then either of them can hold of Luke.