NJO Luke Skywalker vs. Darth Revan

It was not the amount of warriors NJO Luke Skywalker killed, it was the way he was connected to the Force, how he used it during slaying these warriors. Luke was given the appearance that he had 10-20 lightsabers in hand. And during this battle Luke even discovered a new Force Power no one else in the galaxy had herd of...Not even Revan, Yoda & etc. If it was because of the amount Luke killed, then Exar Kun would be seen as a great warrior as well. Luke in NJO has an ability in the Force like no one else in the history of the Jedi and Sith. That is why he would win this battle, but I don't know why people are still arguing over this, the poll is closed and NJO Luke Skywalker is the victor.

Originally posted by HimoKun
[B]First of all, ROTJ is not during NJO, so he didn't fight anyone of his calibre during NJO.

ROTJ is before NJO. You have to start somewhere. There is nothing in the entire SW universe that would match NJO Luke in NJO times.

The Mandalorians had shields that would block melee damage and lightsabre damage, and they had Balsilisk War Suits whcih were probably twice as powerful as the armour the Vong wear.

Err..Armor twice as powerful the one that the Vong wear...what is twice as powerful as something that can not be penetrated by blasterfire or lightsaber hits ? "Look ! The Death Star !" - "I don't care...my armour will block that hit..." ? Sorry when I get some kind of sarcastic here...
And...It took hundrets or thousands of KOTOR time Jedi Knights/Padawans + Malak + Revan to defeat the Mandalorians. One NJO Luke was enough to defeat the Yuuzhan Vong.

And the Reborn Emperor was killed by Han in a crash into Byss. And Exar Kun was not a Sith Alchemist, he was a Dark Side of the force user. He was trained a Jedi, so he would use force training instead of Sith Alchemy. He didn't create life forms, he mutilated the Massasi.

Erm...actually Palpatine is getting killed many times in the Dark Empire series, finaly by Han Solo who shot in his back. Yes. But Luke did kill him also (first time he reappears).
And Exar Kun used Sith Alchemy and he created life forms with it. It is stated in the Jedi Academy trilogy by Kevin J. Anderson somewhere (I think in the last book the body of Luke gets attacked by creatures that Exar Kun created). Since Anderson is the creator of Exar Kuns history he should know what Exar did or did not.

It took hundrets or thousands of KOTOR time Jedi Knights/Padawans + Malak + Revan to defeat the Mandalorians. One NJO Luke was enough to defeat the Yuuzhan Vong.

Also I stopped before TFP and TUF what is the power that Luke learned?

Originally posted by Darth Plagues
It was not the amount of warriors NJO Luke Skywalker killed, it was the way he was connected to the Force, how he used it during slaying these warriors. Luke was given the appearance that he had 10-20 lightsabers in hand. And during this battle Luke even discovered a new Force Power no one else in the galaxy had herd of...Not even Revan, Yoda & etc. If it was because of the amount Luke killed, then Exar Kun would be seen as a great warrior as well. Luke in NJO has an ability in the Force like no one else in the history of the Jedi and Sith. That is why he would win this battle, but I don't know why people are still arguing over this, the poll is closed and NJO Luke Skywalker is the victor.

The polls are nice but definitely not too accurate sometimes. While this one may be, I have seen Sidious beat Yoda, Yoda beat Revan, and Revan beat Sidious. How does that work? The polls more or less show how the fight would go, if it's close the fight would be close, if it's a blowout the fight's too onesided.

The polls only show who has more fan boys, out of the 14 who voted for luke maybe 4 could actually defend him/make any valid points for him.

Nai Fohl has beaten me. I will not argue anymore. My vote is pulled out, so it's Luke versus Revan with a 2 point lead. 14/12.

Originally posted by Darth_Frobo
The polls only show who has more fan boys, out of the 14 who voted for luke maybe 4 could actually defend him/make any valid points for him.

Very true.

I resent that, I am no fanboy, I just try to see every side equally and say the facts that I know

and I like to think I bring something to a thread and make some decent points, however if that was not refering to me, please ignore my last 2 posts

I watched Star Wars 3 again. Man do those red guys get owned so badly by Yoda

that they do, but I'm not sure what my avatar should be, do you have any ideas? Also, who can create a decent bottom pic?

Nice avatar change. And anyone with a signature pic can make one. Depends on whose you like, and whether you want it personalized. I failed to mention this earlier, but, on the subject of sig pictures, Bobafetty's new one is particulary pleasing to view. Good job.

Thanks Dipsit, do you think you could make me a sig pic then, I want the pic from this site incorperated in
'http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Ulic_qel_droma.jpg'
Thats all that I can think of now, but if you think of something that you think would also suit me and look good you can add it in. Also, if you could personalize it, put in 'Lord Darkstar' (not Revan Darkstar, I changed my name)

Anyway, if you want to do this, thanks and please PM me if you will

Testing...

Lord Darkstar, here is your second choice:

Second one looks better I think. 😉

Thanks Fohl. And Darkstar, if you like neither, tell me and I will make more, according to any further specifications. Thank you for your time, friend. And try to give me a ballpark rating for the work, if you choose one, so I can see how close to the mark I got. Later, man.

Thanks Dipsit, I went with the second one (as you can probably see), I think I would give this an 7 or 8 out of 10, so well done. Thanks again

BTW, full potential Anakin could whoop NJO Luke so there!!!!

Yes, if he ever reached full potential... He could most likely beat anyone, if he was at full potential of course...