I just think that its becuase I saw all six movies through a teenagers eye. I have seen Ep3 three times, and each time I thought that it was that it was simply a great film. Nothing more, nothing less. On my first viewing I stumbled out of the theater and could barely talk for ten minutes afterward. Batman Begins ultiamtely just didn't quite cut it for me. It was a few decimal points shy of perfection, but there was just one thing missing from it. I don't know what it was, but it was missing something. So ultimately I have to judge both on the repeat viewing factor. And ROTS wins. Everytime I see it, I never get bored. Batman on the other hand, felt like a dark, but otherwise standard comic book movie. I thought that Spiderman 2 was a near perfect film, but I only saw it once, and I predict the same for Begins.
That enough explanation for you?
Looks like my suggested addition to the poll helped even things out a bit.
Sorry about the tone.
I think that it is the best for the follwoing reasons: the dialouge in episode 3 was actually pretty good for Star Wars standards. The films emotional angle hit me right we're it need. I have never felt as emotional as I did watching any other Star Wars film. The story itself was peferfect. Almost anyone could probably understand what was going on. Little to no political mumbo jumbo, the reason for anakin's turn felt credible to me, and even
Spoiler:came across as merely akward, not bad. The film has the best lightsaber duels I have ever seen, and the other action scenes we're great as well. Ny only quibble with them, was that I felt that some of them could have used a little more time, but that's just a matter of personal taste. The visuals in this film are simply the best I have seen. Everything has a slightly more realistic look to it, and alot of the totally CGI characters, looked pretty life like. Thats my two cents on why its better.
the nooooooo!
This are Maddox two cents, on why it sucked...and he got some points....good ones I mean.
Originally posted by general-pain
I don't exactly trust a guy who says that if you disagree with them, then you are wrong.
And it did kind of suck...I actually felt raped, not right afterwards...but when I though aboot it......George Lucas ****ed up everything he created with the PT...
Originally posted by SnakeEyes
Yeah, that guy was a little harsh, (and when I say a little, I mean he really acted like an ass and complained about everything). Sure, he had some points, because the movie wasn't perfect, but IMO it didn't suck. But to each his own, right?
I think Maddox just likes to piss people off sometimes.
Originally posted by Bardock42
Well this is just ignorant, just because Maddx is ignorant doesn't mean that he's wrong 😛And it did kind of suck...I actually felt raped, not right afterwards...but when I though aboot it......George Lucas ****ed up everything he created with the PT...
well this guy was never gonna like the film as he hated the other 5 as he writes at the bottom. the only bit that i agree with is him is the bit about Lucas is saying it is for children. i mean it got a 12 rating for ****s sake.
Also the bit about anakin turning is ridiculous this guy is chatting crap, it's not even worth being called an opinion.
i'm talking about maddx who i think is a bit of an *******.