best jedi swordsman

Definitely Anakin, followed by Obi. Among the bad guys Darth Maul.

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
Hardly, Obi-Wan won because Anakin got sloppy and thats already been stated by people on the OS.

Sloppy does not a Jedi make. Obi-Wan was not sloppy, that is why Anakin is legless.

and armless.

Samuel L Jackson is as good a swordsman then the guy who played Sidious (I dont feel like typing his name out 😆 )

Maybe Sidious did underestimate Mace but even if he didnt then Sidious still would have lost. I refuse to think that Sidious wouldnt have struck Mace Windu down in the lightsaber fight if he could have. 💃

What are you on about?

Did you even see Sidious fighting Yoda???

Use your brain please and put Mace where Yoda was when he was fighting Sidious..

Originally posted by DeVi| D0do
He's obviously very good. He took down Obi-Wan and Anakin in Clones and also held his own for a while with Yoda. Though obviously knew he couldn't beat him so ran away.

I definitely wouldn't put him above Episode III Anakin or Yoda though. Or even Obi-Wan.

Just a reminder that he had the DEATH STAR plans with him. He HAD to leave.

Well, that clearly wasn't the case when he fought Mace. (Rhyme Alert!)

I have to agree with others that Palps wasn't expecting so much from Windu, resulting in a near-fatal error.

what are you talking about? palpatine just had to create Vader out of anakin and if he needed to he could still have killed mace w/the force

Obi-wan or Yoda definetely. MAce is ok too, but not as good.

Originally posted by Kenpokarate 2
Samuel L Jackson is as good a swordsman then the guy who played Sidious (I dont feel like typing his name out 😆 )

Maybe Sidious did underestimate Mace but even if he didnt then Sidious still would have lost. I refuse to think that Sidious wouldn't have struck Mace Windu down in the lightsaber fight if he could have. 💃

its Ian who ur thinking of (palpatine) and i hate to tell you this but most of palps fighting was not Ian, it was a GC Palpatine 😉 (Ian is too old to do stuff like that) only the close ups were Ian, everything else was CG.

and as for your comment "I refuse to think that Sidious wouldn't have struck Mace Windu down in the lightsaber fight if he could have."

I dont want to repeat everything I already said, so please go read what i said earlier, its all there.

Originally posted by Sith_Dreamer
Obi-wan or Yoda definetely. MAce is ok too, but not as good.

how could you possibly think that Obi-Wan is a better swordsman than MAce are you right in the head

Originally posted by Dresta
how could you possibly think that Obi-Wan is a better swordsman than MAce are you right in the head

yea, Obi was behind mace for sure...

mace would have been 3...

with obi being 5

Have anything to back that claim up, Anom? (dude, i don't mean that as a challenge 😛)

And I'm talking movie-wise, not from some guy who works with GL.

*sigh*

Palps and Yoda are obvious 1/2

mace is an obvious next in line

Anakin is obviously better then Obi

making obi after that (or 5)

Sorry for the trouble, Anom.

Anyway, thank you for pointing that out.

Originally posted by ((The_Anomaly))
*sigh*

Palps and Yoda are obvious 1/2

mace is an obvious next in line

Anakin is obviously better then Obi

making obi after that (or 5)

i's have obi over ani...

mace over palps...

Obi-Wan is a better Jedi than Anakin, but not a better swordsman...

I agree with Anomaly.

yes...

now I knew people would disagree because of the palps losing to windu and the obi beating anakin...

but in both cases they should not have lost. Anakin was WAYYY better then Obi was (example: Dooku) and Palps underestimated Windu (as said in my previous arguments)

and it is known that Yoda is the best of the Jedi, and had pretty much a stalemate with Palpatine in thier saber match.

Originally posted by DeVi| D0do
Obi-Wan is a better Jedi than Anakin, but not a better swordsman...

I agree with Anomaly.

yes, thanks, I agree. Obi-Wan was a better jedi then Anakin, but anakin was more powerful.. in force and swordsmanship.

Obviously not in smarts though.