Is KOTOR better than ROTS?

Allright, let's look at it in a scientific standpoint: In ROTS when R2D2 beat the Buzz-droid, it blew off the starfighter's wing, even though they are in space. When grevious's ship tips up, everyone falls as of they were on a planet, but they are not. ROTS is a Hollywood style move where things blow up for no reason, and non-existant forces affect things.

Oh and further more, the dialouge in KOTOR is beter than in ROTS!

I'd refer have forshadowing than only Vader being in the last five minutes, and delivering the worst dialog in the Saga.
KotOR had depth, which ROTS didnt, and KotOR two is far more of a thinking mans game. KotOR was better written, it atleast didnt have Grevious going out like a B!tch.

Yea, no shit, that's why they should put us in charge.

Originally posted by Fierce Deity
Allright, let's look at it in a scientific standpoint: In ROTS when R2D2 beat the Buzz-droid, it blew off the starfighter's wing, even though they are in space. When grevious's ship tips up, everyone falls as of they were on a planet, but they are not. ROTS is a Hollywood style move where things blow up for no reason, and non-existant forces affect things.

Oh and further more, the dialouge in KOTOR is beter than in ROTS!

Yea, no shit, that's why they should put us in charge.

Yes, but you can't argue.

No, we can't argue. You're too thick to realize reason.

Meh, ROTS was much better. KotOR was just one huge contradiction.

Red Lightsabres being first used at Ruusan? Nah, lets change that.

Darth first being used by Bane? Nah, lets change that.

The entire feel and look of the TOTJ series? Nah, lets change that.

The Jedi creating a wall of light over Yavin? Nah, lets change that.

The Valley of Dark Lords being a gigantic area? Nah, lets change that.

Naga Sadow having a tomb? WTF!?

Originally posted by Traya
Meh, ROTS was much better. KotOR was just one huge contradiction.

Red Lightsabres being first used at Ruusan? Nah, lets change that.

Darth first being used by Bane? Nah, lets change that.

The entire feel and look of the TOTJ series? Nah, lets change that.

The Jedi creating a wall of light over Yavin? Nah, lets change that.

The Valley of Dark Lords being a gigantic area? Nah, lets change that.

Naga Sadow having a tomb? WTF!?

Meh I never really cared. TOTJ was ugly (ships with fins? WTF?) and seeing as how things get reconned all the time it's not like it really matters anyway. Although how Naga Sadow managed to get a tomb on Korriban is... a bit strange.
And anyway to fix the Darth thing with KOTOR they made Darth what's his name who existed like way before KOTOR.

As for Red lightsabers? Well hey maybe Revan started a trend... not like it matters what color lightsaber is used.

KOTOR was an excellent game and although it cannot match up to ROTS (you just can't compaire a game with a movie) why people get annoyed just because it contradicts the great and holy TOTJ is beyond me.

Because it's an obvious ploy to cash in on the prequels...

Meh, I prefered the TOTJ look.

IT's kind of strange, with Ludo and Naga having tombs since
A. Ludo was vaporized in space and held the self proclaimed title for a day or two perhaps.
B. Naga died on Yavin 4 and held the title for a very short time.
C. I really doubt the Sith, in the midst of being exterminated would be willing to big tombs for the guys whose rivalry screwed them

Originally posted by Janus Marius
No, we can't argue. You're too thick to realize reason.

Realize, reason? What the hell is that supposed to mean?

Point proven.

doh

Again, I stand by the fact that the lead actors of ROTS were quite poor. KOTOR had better voice acting from its leads (except Revan duh!) but not only that, the plot was well developed. We already knew what happens in ROTS, and for me it detracted from the experience.

Both sides had a lot of hard work put into it. Some people like the movie, some people like the game. I for one think that in terms of legacy, ROTS wins. In terms of quality though... KOTOR breaks ROTS on its knees.

Ewan and Ian were great, but that's about it.

Agreed.

I think Sam was also pretty good.

KOTOR was fun and all but, if you beat it and you little cousin erases the file you tend to hate both of them....

ohhh...well KOTor games are good for replaying so do be hatin'

well its not my fault entirely i saved the second one which i think rocks hard core and i havent put it down since august......woah

Originally posted by Lightsnake
IT's kind of strange, with Ludo and Naga having tombs since
A. Ludo was vaporized in space and held the self proclaimed title for a day or two perhaps.
B. Naga died on Yavin 4 and held the title for a very short time.
C. I really doubt the Sith, in the midst of being exterminated would be willing to big tombs for the guys whose rivalry screwed them

"There hasnt been a full scale war since the formation of the Republic." BULL SHIT!

Padmea only held Luke, so how could his sister remember her???

And dont be b!thching about the change of look from TOTJ and KotOR, look at the technological down grade from the PT to the OT. at least KotOR looked like the galaxy was in a sense of progress.

Oh, I forgot the third post.