Dooku and Windu

You say tomato I say tomato.

Whether EU contradicts or not doesn't matter.

Now, let's watch the rest of the boards make silly comments and quote Mace... 🙄

Dooku: Die Mace! (Force lighting)

Yup, see what I mean?

Only did that cause you said it.

Have fun with that.

Didn't Mace say: Jedis are keepers of the peace, not soldiers?
But weren't they generals in the Clone War?

Mace's da dumbest Sw character ever

The dumbest Star Wars character ever was an extra in the Tatooine Cantina. He had an IQ of...something.

Mace Windu said that not knowing that they were going to enter a huge-ass war. Plus, Palpatine put them in that position so that Order 66 would go to work right away once he called it.

I hate Palp!

Palpsy is a feckin' genius.

Yeah, he's da biggest SW genius ever

If he was such a genuis why did he die?

Jeez, Einstein died too

He wasn't killed by the one person he tried to become evil at any cost.

Though, Einstein wasn't thrown into a pit by his pupil...did he even have a pupil?

Palpatine didn't see it coming. Doesn't matter if your a genius if the Dark Side is clouding everything. Dark Side can cloud the Dark Side, after all. Otherwise, Palpatine would have forseen Vader's turn.

.....................................................ok 😄

Chilled Monkey: are you really insinuating that Windu is more powerful than Palpatine. Ok, in that case that makes him more powerful than Yoda as well. Be careful of the way the movie presents it. Take a look at Lucas' original ideas and you'll be surprised at how the fight really should have gone. The only reason this happened was to keep people like you happy. After all, the Sith can't win all the time.

Please don't tell me that you though Sidious was serious when he was lying there saying 'im too weak, please don't kill me. Please'. It sounds so pathetically fake. Anakin's intervention was paramount. To say it wasnt intended would be outrageous. Oh yes, Palpatine didn't know Anakin was on his way. Of course he knew, he could FEEL it if you know what that means. He obviously fell for a purpose. TO convince ANakin that it wasn't an arrest, but an assasination, which was diabolically brilliant. Only the mind of a Sith could do that. Brilliant. Besides, then there's Yoda 'the dark side clouds everythign'. Hmmm. Wonder who that was? What a fool. It took Mace to wake everyone up. Still no one will deny what Palpatine did was brilliant. Even the Jedi didn't know.

I completely agree with Valar, though I will not state why because I hate repeating myself about 1000 times...

Palpatine was brilliant...and twistedly evil. 😄

Originally posted by Valar Melkor
Chilled Monkey: are you really insinuating that Windu is more powerful than Palpatine. Ok, in that case that makes him more powerful than Yoda as well. Be careful of the way the movie presents it. Take a look at Lucas' original ideas and you'll be surprised at how the fight really should have gone. The only reason this happened was to keep people like you happy. After all, the Sith can't win all the time.

Please don't tell me that you though Sidious was serious when he was lying there saying 'im too weak, please don't kill me. Please'. It sounds so pathetically fake. Anakin's intervention was paramount. To say it wasnt intended would be outrageous. Oh yes, Palpatine didn't know Anakin was on his way. Of course he knew, he could FEEL it if you know what that means. He obviously fell for a purpose. TO convince ANakin that it wasn't an arrest, but an assasination, which was diabolically brilliant. Only the mind of a Sith could do that. Brilliant. Besides, then there's Yoda 'the dark side clouds everythign'. Hmmm. Wonder who that was? What a fool. It took Mace to wake everyone up. Still no one will deny what Palpatine did was brilliant. Even the Jedi didn't know.

More powerful, no. Windu won the fight because his skill is greater.

Yes, I know Palpatine was exaggerating hugely with his 'im too weak, please don't kill me. Please'. He is highly intelligent and good at turning situations to his advantage. His 'helpless' routine was done to get Anakin's support. Support that he NEEDED as he couldn't win alone.