Darth Revan and Darth Malak vs. NJO Luke and Mace Windu

I don't really know.... I think Luke could take Revan, but Malak could take Mace. But I need opinions.

good battle

seriously, this is a good battle

i think the jeedai would take this though. revan would fight luke to a stand still, malak and windu would be a very good fight as well, but i think in the end mace would overcome malak and come to help out luke. revan cant take both of those jeedai at the same time.

seriously this is a good fight, its been a while since ive seen one on this forum

i agree with human vader, mace takes malak and wins, luke and revan fight but are almost equal in power, and finaly mace joins luke and overpowers revan.

mace vs malak is a real tough battle and could change the destiny of the other fight but after research i have to say mace would win and go help luke against revan

Thank you, it's my first thread. I agree, except I think the Jedi might lose Mace in the process. But your scenario is possible as well.

I agree. It depends on who falls first. It'll either be Mace or Malak I think, because it would take Luke longer to kill Revan than it would Mace to kill Malak, or vice-versa. Thing is, I think that Malak might somehow be able to beat Mace. It's certainly possible, but I need more opinions.

Well I agree with Human Vader.

I think Revan is slightly stronger than NJO Luke, but by a very small margin. Mace could beat Malak fast enough to go help Luke finish Revan. Jedi have this. Luke might die though. Good thread.

It all comes down to ether Mace or Malak dying. Mace would most likley win and then could save Luke's ass from getting whipped by Revan.

I agree; it's possible. If Malak falls, the Jedi win. BUt I think Malak's a bit stronger than Mace.

Well, it all depends on your logic. A lot of people think Mace<Sidious. And Malak, being a Sith lord around the time of the Golden Era of the Sith (Someone who reigned for a year during a war with the Republic, with some couple thousand Sith beneath him)

Forgive me for always playing devil's advocate, but when I see so many people say with utmost conviction Mace can take Malak (And I doubt hardly any of you read Shatterpoint, the best EU source on the man) I get a bit troubled. Now... Malak was a Sith lord. He was a master of combat and darkness, having served frontline in the Mandalorian Wars, having slain enemies and potential usurpers throughout his dark career. He is the only known wielder of a great lightsaber, witha blade of easily four feet. His Force mastery is very good, enabling him to destroy two Jedi before facing Revan. An act that, at the very least, puts him on par with or above Dooku. Dooku, who beat Mace windu in combat previously. Dooku who has nowhere near the merits and experience of Malak himself. So really, you should be asking yourselves, is Mace better than an ancient Sith lord?

And as for Revan and Luke, they are the figureheads of the new factions on this board, Anakin having taken a back seat since Episode III came out. I won't touch on that. But until KOTOR III comes out, Revan's true potential and abilities remain unknown. I would, however, based on all I know of him (And his being better than Malak) he would be only slightly weaker than Exar Kun. And Exar Kun in his living days would spank even NJO Luke around like a ragdoll.

Well Mace's Vaapad Form gives him the upper hand against Malak.

mace and malak are the deciding factors of the fight,
it is said that mace is an extremely good duelist but so is malak.

so ummmmm im leaning toward malak now after what darth janus posted but i have really no idea

I mostly agree with Glentract. Lord Revan and NJO Luke are really close and that fight would drag on for quite a while and I do think Revan would win, if slightly. Mace and Malak would last a while I think but IMO Malak's only slightly stronger than Dooku who is weaker than the Emperor who lost to Mace so Mace would eventually kill Darth Malak and help Luke kill Revan.

Thank you Janus; while I completely agree with your deductions on Malak (you'll find I said the same in my earlier posts), I doubt Exar could "spank Luke around like a ragdoll". I believe he could win, but Luke would put up a decent fight. But yes, I believe Luke may be defeated by Kun, and that Mace would fall to Malak. And General, Mace's Vaapad is certainly helpful, but I doubt it'll give him much of an advantage against someone of Malak's calibre. I've noticed Malak is given little respect on this forum; many underestimate him.

Far to many, Malak was a great fighter even when he was young. He became a lot better, the thing is however most people think he is weak because he refused to face Revan and always tried to delay the fight when he knew it was coming. And really I can't blame him.

As for Revan vs Luke, I have said I think Revan would win enough. But seeing as people hate that I will now say they are equal, however Malak has been trained with Revan. He knows how Revan fights they fought a lot together. They were best friends, together they would defeat almost anybody. Luke stands no chance against the two of them.

Not to mention that I don't think it would be actually 1vs1 and 1vs1 more Malak and Revan working together in a really good way until the other two are dead but thats just speculation of course.

Well, the whole Luke being spanked thing was exaggeration, but I was irked. It happens. Realistically, NJO Luke is quite the force to be reckoned with. But when he is elevated to god status just because people despite Revan, or Ragnos, or Exar Kun, I go off on a tangent.

I was going to do a poll but too many people are just obsessed with certain characters; they'd give no reasons and just vote for who they liked. Anyways, I agree with you Fishy, but I think Mace and Luke could work pretty well; they both have similar philosiphies in their use of the Force, but Revan and Malak's experience with eachother in battle would undermine this. I personally think the darksiders could take this; if Revan and Malak tried to fight together, then Luke and Mace ccould break them up. Luke is more powerful than Malak, so he could probably get him out of the way for a bit while he and Mace double-teamed Revan, but this is more likely to happen in Revan and Malak's case; Revan could lightning or throw Mace, and the two Sith could take Luke. But this is all speculation.

Luke and Mace would be a good team. Two of the strongest Jedi Masters fighting two of the strongest Sith Lords. In the end I think Luke and Mace would win.

I agree Janus, which is why I didn't do a poll; the fanboys would vote for the people they worship.

A good team, yes. But Revan and Malak's comraderie is the stuff of legends.