Darth Revan and Darth Malak vs. NJO Luke and Mace Windu

Zodiac on crack, yet again my friend.

Windu, you and I are going to get along just fine. Grab an icon or avatar so you stick out better. I rather like your way of thinking.

Not to sound rude General, but you don't get it. Darth Revan is one of the most powerful Force-users of all time. If you value the opinions of others on the thread, check out the Yoda vs. Revan one. If Revan defeated Yoda according to some people, then how can Mace hold Revan off for longer than Malak can Luke? It's possible, now that I think about it, but it's probably not as likely.

And to make you happy, the setting is in the Dune Sea, on Tatooine. And please, nobody say that Luke's Skywalker side will take over and he'll be stupid and jump into the Sarlacc Pit. 🙂

Thank you Janus. And Zodiac I respect you for your persistence.

Originally posted by General Zodiac
Hmm... You said Luke is equal to or better then Revan. Revan beat the **** out of Malak in their duel on that ship. Mace on the other hand would be able to keep Revan busy till Luke's done.

Based on what?

Yeah Revan was more powerful then Malak but he still needed his time to beat Malak. And how do you compare Mace to Malak again? Right you don't, you base this on nothing but your own believes. And Luke would not face Malak, he wouldn't get the chance.

I'll get to that. 🙂

If Mace was a frontline general in the Clone Wars and slaughtered at least twenty or so Force users of reasonable skill, I would say he has a better chance against Malak. That's how I compare apples and pears. I find something they have similar, such as the immigrant picking them, and I match them up.

Well Mace was a frontline general in the Clone Wars, but he didn't touch a Force-user except in his duel with Ventress.

But I get your point.

Was that in one of those Scholastic Clone Wars books? I didn't read those... Couldn't bear being caught in the kids fiction section, buying them.

I got my mom to get the for me. JK.

Anyway, Janus, about how you said earlier that Malak is very underrated, I think that may be true to a small degree(this itself probably sounds like underration to some people). Mace solidly wupped Sidious though and I think he could take Malak.

About what you said about the greatlightsaber, I have read in several different places that it is a lightsaber around ten feet long, so Malak's isnt even close.

Same difference; he used an unusually large blade, which took great skill to use effectively, and altered his combat style.

True enough. I was under the impression the great lightsaber was smaller than that. I think you're thinking of the enormous, unwieldy prototypes, that the Old Republic soldiers used as weapons. But in any case, his blade is longer than Revan is tall. If you don't believe me, type ~ in KOTOR, and type in giveitem g_w_lghtsbr06

That's Malak's lightsaber.

Didn't I hear most people say that NJO Luke is thr strongest Jedi?

Yes, and that was probably from the fanboys. I too agree with that, but the strongest Force-user of all was probably one of the Sith, and it most likely would have been Anakin Skywalker had not Kenobi done his little ninja act.

Anakin definately had the potential. But the mindset he lacked. He had no control. And now he's paying half off at the tanning salon, so it doesn't matter really.

lol

Back to the battle, shall we? Although I must admimt, this little detour as amusing.

? suspo

If Kreia could kill three jedi masters with a wave of her hand, at the same time, Revan was stronger than Kreia, so what makes you think Revan couldnt do the same to Mace?

Because Mace is stronger then those 3 Jedi Masters. Sidious killed 3 in 3 seconds but not Mace.