no snape is good.. he killed DD on his orders... DD wasn't pleading for Snape to save him he was pleading for him to kill him. DD knew that Draco wouldn't kill him but Snape had to to save draco's family because of the unbreakable vow... Harry knows everything he needs to know to defeat the dark lord
Originally posted by Fwiw187
no snape is good.. he killed DD on his orders... DD wasn't pleading for Snape to save him he was pleading for him to kill him. DD knew that Draco wouldn't kill him but Snape had to to save draco's family because of the unbreakable vow... Harry knows everything he needs to know to defeat the dark lord
and there's proof of this...where?
Phoenix is right, Draco is not evil. And I don't think thta Voldemort is pure evil, too because there has to be something good in him. He became evil because he was left alone in his childhood and he knew he was special, he could do things others couldnt and there is still slytherin's blood in his veins and so that was a way to react. I think Draco was raised to be evil, but he could turn to good. He was crying and everything.
I don't think Snape killed Dumbledore on his orders, that would be unbelieveable, and it would not save Snape, even if he had died otherwise. Now he is gonna end up in Azkaban, isnt he?
about dumbledore dying, my sis. thinks that he left a horcrux of himself so he stays alive, but that would mean that dumbledore killed sum1 and i dont think he would do that. i dont really believe that he's dead 'cause isnt dumbledore practicly the only thing that protected harry from volemort besides his mother's blood?
i guess its possible that harry could be a horcrux. i does explain alot, like why they are able to see into eachothers minds, and why snape protects him. but then again why would voldemort make harry the horcrux when he went there to kill him but the spell backfired,like it wouldnt work. i think that maybe voldie made the horcrux into something that was at harry's house in godric's hollow. liek didnt dd say that voldie wanted to put a horcrux into somethign that belonged to each founder? and JK said that there was a connection between godric griffindor and godric's hollow. maybe he was able to find somethign in godric's hollow that he thought would be sufficient enough for a horcrux, that maybe once belonged to godric. he he used james or lily's (prolly james) death as what would split his soul. wow i just stumbled across that right now lol.
I just thought off something (yeah it's a little off-the-wall but work with me people) I believe that the Sorting Hat might be a horcrux... I believe it was Godric Griffindor's and I remember reading and interview from JKR an she said that there was more to the Sorting Hat then what we know... I dunno... Like I said, it's a little off-the-wall
Originally posted by Skull_Racer
about dumbledore dying, my sis. thinks that he left a horcrux of himself so he stays alive, but that would mean that dumbledore killed sum1 and i dont think he would do that. i dont really believe that he's dead 'cause isnt dumbledore practicly the only thing that protected harry from volemort besides his mother's blood?
I don't think dumby would have done that, we went on and on about how wrong it was to split the soul and how voldie had 'maimed' his soul
I don't think Voldie went to Godric's Hollow with the intention of making harry a horcrux - why would he have made the killing curse on H if he had? I think he was going to use Harry's death to make his last horcrux ((cos he only liked to use very special deaths)). He probs had it all set up, as I would have thought death energy doesn't last long, and all he had to do was direct it into its holder. When the killing curse rebounded, I think he panicked and used his own death to make his last Horcrux, as he was dying, and either the spell went wrong and Harry ended up as the horcrux or he just sent his soul into the nearest thing, which would be harry