Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince - Book 2005

Originally posted by tigress
i felt betrayed all this time waiting it was a good plot but was let down I felt that it was rushed too, and what was with the time jumping she never did that in the first five at least the chapters followed on so much was left out and whats with the bloody savage warewolf talk about eeeeeeeeeep i had the childrens version it was still to gorey my 6 year old wants me to read it to her there aint no way in hell im reading it to her yet shell freak out,

there's a childrens version?

I think Draco has some good in him. Draco may become a member of the Order of the Phoenix or Voldy will kill him.

i feel sorry for him!

but is that realy posible to die at the same time? OR he could kill voldimort and then him self...LOL

mmm i dont think harry is a horcrux, but i do think that the writing of the prophecy isnt really straight, becuz you kinda get from it that both have to die... i dunno. but then again, harry and voldy do have the ability to see into eachothers minds.

Originally posted by daeri
Harry isn't a horcrux.. because he has to kill him self first before he kills voldemort..

Precisely.

Originally posted by TinkrBellBaBii
for those who have already read the book . . .
(PLEASE DON'T READ IF YOU HAVEN'T FINISHED THE BOOK!!)

ok i just finished the book today and i was wondering what you guys thought about this. It was just a kind of daydream I had about what might happen in the 7th book ...

Harry said at the end of HBP that he probably wasnt going to return to Hogwarts and that he was going to look for the other Horcruxes and once that is accomplished, kill Voldemort. Do any of you think its possible that Harry himself could be one of Voldemort's Horcruxes? Dumbledore did tell Harry that it was possible to have a living creature or a human as a Horcrux. This would also explain why the prophecy stated "neither can live while the other survives" as both Harry and Voldemort would have to die.

please give me your opinions, i'd like to hear what some of you guys think about it. thanks 🙂

How do you assume that, if Voldemort dies, Harry must die too, from "neither can live while the other survives"? All that is saying is that, while these two are alive, they cannot survive, meaning one must destroy the other (possibly dying in the consequences, but that's besides the point.)

I think many people are misled, and they translate "neither can live while the other survives" to "neither can live while the other *dies*". If this was what was said in the Prophecy, than it would make sense to assume that Harry would have to die if Voldemort did, for he cannot *live* while the other *dies.*

if harry was a horxcrux that would be a rip off ending, jk's better then that.

ha ha true to that...LOL

I think Draco will turn ✅

Originally posted by Saberstylemasta
You can edit your posts ya know.

Stupid n00b...

HBP was good, but it could have been a lot better. I like it, but it is my least favorite

play nice Dark 😆

i still think that he will turn out like his father in azkaban. he's an idiot.

i still think he will turn out like his dad in azkaban.he's an idiot.

I wouldn't call him an "idiot". He blindsided the entire school of Hogwarts and fooled Dumbledore himself.

He may be "evil" in a sense.

he joined lord voldenort. thats idiot enouph for me.

He had no choice. Voldie said "If you don't join me and do what I say, I'm gonna kill, maim, rape your mom and dad."

I think it might be possible for Snape to still be good and that he was doing what Dumbly told him too, but one think, how is he sopposed to tell the Order that now???

Dumbledore should've known that they wouldn't trust Snape ever again!!!!!

Originally posted by Movie_Geek_
Did anyone notice the fact that dumbledore said to Draco that Lord V can not kill you if you are already dead. It is the argument going on in my house over whether that means dumbledore planed the hole thing with Snape. When you read it it is as though he is telling Draco how he could protect him, but there may be more to it. I think he is dead but....I would like to think there is still a chance. I think we all want to think he is still alive. The best way to convince Lord V. that dumbledore was dead and that Snape had turned was to tell no one of there plan. Well dose any one think that he is still alive. I think he is dead

wow that is a really good idea, but believe he is dead, i dont think that Snape pretended to kill him so that Voldemort would think he's dead but he's actully not. But maybe there is a way Dumbledore can communicate to Harry and help him with the Horcruxes. As he said "VOldemort cant kill you if you already dead."

Its a good idea and the only, and i mean ONLY idea i would except as Snape still being good. Otherwise i refuse to belive that Snape is good.

I still hate him.