Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince - Book 2005

don't know how i'm going to survive...i'm dying to know what happens...

you should kidnap JR and ask her 😛

If Snape's being a Death Eater is a facade it's an exceedingly elaborate one. He must have done enough to convince Voldemort by now.

That's a good idea...maybe i shoild try...lol

Originally posted by shaber
If Snape's being a Death Eater is a facade it's an exceedingly elaborate one. He must have done enough to convince Voldemort by now.

Originally posted by Saratn
That's a good idea...maybe i shoild try...lol

Bellatrix is the sort of character to be convinced by Dumbledore's execution.

Now when I get to Scotland, where do i go from their????

Originally posted by Saratn
But the Dark Lord's Imperius Curse would be stronger than the one the imposter put on Harry during the lesson. He has more hate, and killed more than Crouch Jr. so thus his Imperius curse would be stronger.

Errr i ment *thought it was obvious* That harry broke out of VOLDERMORTS imperius curse. He put one on harry in the grave yard and tried to make him bow remember?

Also there is only one reason why i believe snape is good at that is because dumbledore pleaded. Im not going to quote it but there is a paragraph about harry CHOOSING to battle dumbledore with his head held high and not being forced to. Saying theres a big diference and dumbledore understood it.

Dumbledore would not plead for his life, that just pathetic. Dumbledore is way above that.

I totally agree with luna... DD wasn't pleading for his life he has pleading..
1) to make the death eaters believe it more
OR
2) he was pleading for snape to kill him
#2 is the one i think or IT COULD be a combanation of both you never know...

Originally posted by shaber
Bellatrix is the sort of character to be convinced by Dumbledore's execution.

Originally posted by Saratn
Now when I get to Scotland, where do i go from their????

Originally posted by Fwiw187
I totally agree with luna... DD wasn't pleading for his life he has pleading..
1) to make the death eaters believe it more
OR
2) he was pleading for snape to kill him
#2 is the one i think or IT COULD be a combanation of both you never know...

They both together would be good points.

I made a few errors in my previous post but if your smart you'll spot them 😛

Originally posted by Saratn
They both together would be good points.

i finished the book over 2 weeks of hockey camp. i liked it alot, the ending felt uncomplete to me in a way. i didnt want to read it in 6 hours without stopping, it takes away the suspense from waiting a while and tryin to put pieces together. ive seen the trailer for HP: and the goblet of fire... looks good, i was just wondering whether JKR will wait another 2 years for the last book, i dont wanna wait that long... hmmm

Originally posted by Sectumsempra
i finished the book over 2 weeks of hockey camp. i liked it alot, the ending felt uncomplete to me in a way. i didnt want to read it in 6 hours without stopping, it takes away the suspense from waiting a while and tryin to put pieces together. ive seen the trailer for HP: and the goblet of fire... looks good, i was just wondering whether JKR will wait another 2 years for the last book, i dont wanna wait that long... hmmm

ahhh something to add, u had a good point about DD and Severus' plan with DDs death, Snape still could be good cuz he disobayed Voldemorts orders for Draco to kill DD and he could have easily killed harry when he threw curses at snape and snape just stood there taking them. so maybe he didnt want to kill harry because he was good, and try buy harry time to get the Horcruxes and destroy them, keeping harry alive meant that he was giving harry a chance to destroy voldemort.... who is R.A.B by the way lol..

Originally posted by Sectumsempra
ahhh something to add, u had a good point about DD and Severus' plan with DDs death, Snape still could be good cuz he disobayed Voldemorts orders for Draco to kill DD and he could have easily killed harry when he threw curses at snape and snape just stood there taking them. so maybe he didnt want to kill harry because he was good, and try buy harry time to get the Horcruxes and destroy them, keeping harry alive meant that he was giving harry a chance to destroy voldemort.... who is R.A.B by the way lol..

and someone said that RAB could be Sirius's brother.

oooooo yaaaaa his brother...damn... i never thought of that.... wow i know u love my theory and i love u for telling me about sirius' brother now i remember... its perfect, sirius' brother died because he betrayed voldemort, before his death however he destroyed a Horcrux.... niceeeeeeee

or he's hidden it somewhere inside that house....
and the part of that note in the locket would make sense...that i'd be dead before you found it' or something amost that line. ✅

and 😂 i'm just reaping what someone else said i didn't guessed that on my own