Originally posted by Saratn
If i were Harry i wouldn't worry about it at the time. i would worry about destroying the horcruxes, then i wouild confront him, where ever he may be.
I think Snape is bad. ANd nothng will make me change that until i read it in the next book. Or if JK tells us herself(which she wont.)
I am not saying that Snape could not possibly be good at all. I agree that a lot of theories point to it. ANd i agree that they are good theories. But I still believe that Snape is bad.
Originally posted by DanZeke25
Naturally I do, but as I have already proven to you, I make mistakes like the next man. In fact, being -- forgive me -- rather cleverer than most men, my mistakes tend to be correspondingly huger.-Albus Dumbledore
Ooh good quote! So it could be talking about his mistake of trusting Snape too. I like it.
Originally posted by DanZeke25
Naturally I do, but as I have already proven to you, I make mistakes like the next man. In fact, being -- forgive me -- rather cleverer than most men, my mistakes tend to be correspondingly huger.-Albus Dumbledore
Here's proof that Dumbledore could have been easily fooled by Snape.
Dumbledore's weakness for seeing the best in everyone allowed him to be foled and betrayed by Snape.
I think that the people who believe Snape is still good believe too much in Dumbledore. He says himself that he is open to mistakes.
I don't think Snape would be able to fool Voldemort because Voldemort does not possess this weakness. Snape would have to prove 100%--beyond a shadow of a doubt--to Voldemort that he was still loyal. A simple 'I am sorry' (as Snape provided for Dumbledore) would have been far inferior to what Voldemort would have required for proving Snape's loyalty. It is because of this fact that I believe Snape would be able to fool Dumbledore, but not Voldemort.
Amen to that brother.
I share the opinion and Snape is evil and he used Dumbedore's vulnerability, but he can not play the same with Voldermort. I just want to see Justice done. Snape should pay for what he did, and Harry should learn not to trust people just because they all should be ok. But I think Potter learned that long before
Originally posted by hotsauce6548
Here's proof that Dumbledore could have been easily fooled by Snape.Dumbledore's weakness for seeing the best in everyone allowed him to be foled and betrayed by Snape.
I think that the people who believe Snape is still good believe too much in Dumbledore. He says himself that he is open to mistakes.
I don't think Snape would be able to fool Voldemort because Voldemort does not possess this weakness. Snape would have to prove 100%--beyond a shadow of a doubt--to Voldemort that he was still loyal. A simple 'I am sorry' (as Snape provided for Dumbledore) would have been far inferior to what Voldemort would have required for proving Snape's loyalty. It is because of this fact that I believe Snape would be able to fool Dumbledore, but not Voldemort.
you have put wot i thought in to words ....thank you
But here's anotherpossibility. I believe that Dumbledore puts the lives of his students before his, so this is what I came up with for a theory...
Snape tells Dumbledore about Malfoy becoming a Death Eater. Dumbledore tells him to go to his house, where Bella and Narcissa come, and Narcissa asks him to take the Unbreakable Vow. Later in the book, Dumbledore talks to Snape, about killing him so he would save himself and Malfoy. Snape doesn't want to so Dumbledore tells him that you've agreed to it, and you must see it through. Dumbledore brings Harry to the cave in search of the Horcrux. Dumbledore drinks the potion, knowing it would weaken him, for when Snape kills him. He didn't want the chance to defend himself. After they get what they thought was the Horcrux, they go back to the school where they see Malfoy, and Dumbledore starts talking to him. Three other Death Eaters come out beside Malfoy telling him to kill Dumbledore. This gives Snape some time to get out of the castle then kills Dumbledore, and escapes with Malfoy. Now the Death Eaters would have no questions about him being with Dumbledore, since he had just killed him.
Originally posted by Saratnexactly ✅
But here's anotherpossibility. I believe that Dumbledore puts the lives of his students before his, so this is what I came up with for a theory...
Snape tells Dumbledore about Malfoy becoming a Death Eater. Dumbledore tells him to go to his house, where Bella and Narcissa come, and Narcissa asks him to take the Unbreakable Vow. Later in the book, Dumbledore talks to Snape, about killing him so he would save himself and Malfoy. Snape doesn't want to so Dumbledore tells him that you've agreed to it, and you must see it through. Dumbledore brings Harry to the cave in search of the Horcrux. Dumbledore drinks the potion, knowing it would weaken him, for when Snape kills him. He didn't want the chance to defend himself. After they get what they thought was the Horcrux, they go back to the school where they see Malfoy, and Dumbledore starts talking to him. Three other Death Eaters come out beside Malfoy telling him to kill Dumbledore. This gives Snape some time to get out of the castle then kills Dumbledore, and escapes with Malfoy. Now the Death Eaters would have no questions about him being with Dumbledore, since he had just killed him.
but i wonder what will Snape do next. coz i doubt that anyone in Order would believe him about that 😕
and if the latter happened...i don't see any point in the whole situation.... because...Snape did it on DD order... and now he will be able to spy on death eaters and voldy even more succesfully...but he won't be able to share this knowledge with anyone, coz they won't beleive him....😕
and i'm wondering what did dumbledore think when he saw snape comming there.. 😕 that he said 'serverus'.. it was weird 😕