Movies vs. EU.

Originally posted by bilb
Ok my bad.. it IS Expanded Universe

and my point is that any decent SW fan would have some reverence for the dude who came up with the damn thing

"IF canon, sw movies and GL (which order you prefer) are God, Does that make EU the Devil? LMAO" - yes , yes it does 😛

You know, before you start coming in here and bashing EU, you need to know what the hell your talking about.

HA! 😆

Nac's on a rampage..RUN FOR THE SHELTER!!!!

Ha

Originally posted by Tulak Hord
Nac's on a rampage..RUN FOR THE SHELTER!!!!

HAHAHA 😆 *Hides when Nactous comes in*

Oh and P.S Tulak...I Like your avatar and sig.

Originally posted by JLRTENJAC
Let's see... hmmm.... This is not very heated but I'm joining and ofcourse I AM siding with EU.

*Runs to the bomb shelter and knocks on door*

HEY NACTOUS, LEMME IN, I'VE GOT A WHOLE RANGE OF WEAPONS, EAVEN HK-47, AND A FEW HK-50's... (Watch for the 50's AST they are programmed to mainly hunt you and Devil DODO if he appears.)

*Hears a blast and whistles* Wow sounds like '50 found a target

Well, well, well.

May I remind people that:

a. The person who controls the copyright controls the canon. That is GL, and his views on the non-canon nature of the EU are clear. What the EU writers think doesn't matter one tiny little damn.

b. In any case, the position that the EU is not canon is the official position of this board.

I have asked time and time again for people to respect that. If you do not believe it, for whatever reason, then I am sorry, but tough.

No more canon debates. That issue, on these boards, is DECIDED.

If you want to argue about the quality of the movies or the EU here, that is fine, but if it lingers as a canon debate, I will close.

Anyone else trying to deliberately argue the canonicity will receive an official warning.

... Everybody here fails. At life. My picture says so.

It may be deicded on these forums, but not as a whole, no one will control what I think.

Then this entire debate is pointless and you should stop now.

Listen ING, do you mind if I call you ING. Were using certin points to see which of the two is better.

I never intended on losesing, espically not in the EU section.

Well the fun has been sucked out of this form... and by the way what's wrong with a discussion of the Canonicity of EU as long as it doesn't get too rough?

Because the canonicity has been stated by LucasFilm for one thing, and just because you don't like it doesn't mean it's not true.

I much prefer the movies. This isn't to say I don't like some EU, I've read many of the books and played quite a few of the games. But while there's some good EU, there's also an overwhelming amount of crap. For me, what happens in the movies is always going to be what really happens, and what happens in a book/game/comic is just something that COULD have happen, but doesn't necessarily mean that it does.

I've said what's wrong, and made my position clear. I WILL close this thrad, so stay off the canon topic.

allright I defanantally will, and I don't think that Nac likes that word anyways.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
I've said what's wrong, and made my position clear. I WILL close this thrad, so stay off the canon topic.

Hold on Damnit, this topic, for the last time has nothing to do with yours, or my opinion of canon. This is simply to decide which is better.

dont argue with mod you idiot

The movies are better.