Natakus's (=D) Amalgam Tournament [Phase 3] {ROUND 1} (Vote now!) Long Pig vs Khell

Originally posted by long pig
Who says Astral form is energy?
Magneto can't sense it, the Fantastic Four's energy sensors that protect their building can't sense it.....but Ironman can?
It's doubtful.

he can actually ... i completely forgot about that but it did happen in the last New Avengers issue..... IM detects strange in his astral from just before he enters a room to speak to him (and others)

Originally posted by Scoobless
he can actually ... i completely forgot about that but it did happen in the last New Avengers issue..... IM detects strange in his astral from just before he enters a room to speak to him (and others)

What was he scanning for/with? Anyone know what issue number it is?

Will be closing this in a few hours. Get your votes in.

hey Nat.... as our newly elected thread head..... can i hear a ruling on whether the mirror thing is allowed (Long Pig creating them to create the shield) ..... it may be important in making my decision

Originally posted by long pig
What armor was he wearing? The normal armor?

What was he scanning for/with? Anyone know what issue number it is?

his current regular armour.... it's the latest issue... 9?... (i think it's 9)

found it.....

ok... it's issue 7 .... lol

🙄

.....

and closer.....

Yes but ib that scan it doesn't look like Strange is trying to hide.

why does astral Strange get a chair? it's not like he'll get tired floating around pretending to stand like a normal person...... 😕

Originally posted by newjak86
Yes but ib that scan it doesn't look like Strange is trying to hide.

it's only there to prove that Iron Man can detect astral forms

Originally posted by Scoobless
it's only there to prove that Iron Man can detect astral forms

Originally posted by newjak86
Yeah but would that work if Strange didn't want to be seen.

i have absolutely no idea.... 🙂

Originally posted by Scoobless
i have absolutely no idea.... 🙂

So, he's sitting there and everyone can see him?
Then, Ironman sees him 100ft away?

But in every single other Astral appearance, no one sees him even those with complete control over the EM spectrum and sensors made to detect energy sources....😬

He obviously was making himself able to be seen. Kinda like when he appears to Namor or others who can't sense him.

Here, when he wants to be seen, he can be by anyone, including non-mystics like Ironman or Namor.

i suppose i have to vote... as it stands, i don't think the mental muddling will have too much affect, but the triple shield is a solid idea (if it's allowed) seems like astral forms can be detected and it's been shown that they are not immune to damage through heat or radiation

strength doesn't really come into play here as one character is intangible......

if a scan gets posted showing Majestics "energy detection" abilities i may reconsider... but i'm voting Long Pig right now...... because he can still definitely affect Blackstrom and i can't say the opposite is true if Blackstrom can't see LP's guy (whatever his name is)

so Long Pig gets my vote....(for the moment)

Originally posted by long pig
So, he's sitting there and everyone can see him?
Then, Ironman sees him 100ft away?

well... it happened the other way around but yeah

Originally posted by long pig
But in every single other Astral appearance, no one sees him even those with complete control over the EM spectrum and sensors made to detect energy sources....😬

well..... apparently IM can.... his computer even knew to say it was an astral form.... so it must have been pre-programmed to recognise that energy type

That art is sooooo bad...🙁

Originally posted by long pig
That art is sooooo bad...🙁

on your scan... yes

on mine...... no

😛

Horrid isn't it? Blah...

My point was, Ironman was only able to pick up the Astral form because Strange was making it so that others could perceive him.