Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
One herald alone would give these three a serious run for their money.The Silver Surfer alone could quite easily whittle this down to Silver Surfer vs GL, and he has a great shot of beating all of them.
The five heralds would cream these guys.
Why is Green Arrow here?
And some people think the JLA stands a chance against Galactus! Sheesh!
🙄
Originally posted by dawsey28
Completely different scenario. This battle doesn't involve EVERY JLA member from past and present.In this fight, 5 JLA members don't stand a chance.
OIC. The most powerful members of the JLA (Superman, Wonder Woman) can't beat the heralds but the entire JLA can beat Galactus? No comment. 🤨
???WTF??? The JLA definitely has a chance. All the Heralds have are brute-guys. The only one with any sort of versatility is Surfer.
If Firelord makes a small-sun-like blast, won't it just make Supes stronger?? Superman, WW, and GL are capable of throwing down with anyone on that list (and I'd say they beat any of them 1-on-1 except Surfer). Green Arrow is admittedly a joke. And how would they ever even see Flash?? He could create a lot of havoc without them even knowing it. Travel speed and fight speed are two very different things.
...talk about a Marvel bias. I'd probably give it to the heralds too (dismissing GA, they're outnumbered, and Flash can mess stuff up but probably couldn't actually kill any of them), but to say the JLA doesn't have a chance here is way too harsh. Add in, say, MM for Arrow and I think it's a very fair fight.
-DM
P.S. And to the "Surfer could take them all himself" arguments, I still don't buy it. Sure, he's the most powerful in this fight, but Supes, WW, and GL match him in fight speed and probably best him in strength. Hell, Kyle (a weaker GL) fought well against him in a crossover. An instant blast of radiation wouldn't just take them out...Surfer would need to know what he's doing, actually manage to hit them, and worry about the ongoing battle. And if he tries anything tricky like telepathy, matter manipulation, etc. any competent GL could hinder him enough to prevent it.
Originally posted by Mider
would be an interesting battle but cant flash take there speed while superman and WW and GL bash there skulls in
A plausible strategy, though they might be able to avoid the speed-drain.
My theory would involved Flash running WW's lasso around and about a bunch of them, have GL anchor the lasso to a construct, so they'd be in one place to beat down on all at once.