Mace Windu vs. Count Dooku in Geonosis Arena

Anyone who types "u guyz" seriously, seriously needs to learn internet ettiquette.

Now, in response to your posts...

Mace>Palpatine does not = Mace>Dooku. I think one interesting fact everyone seems to ignore in here is that just because Mace can beat Palpatine doesn't mean he can easily take Yoda or Dooku, two people commonly thought to be less or just about equal to Palpatine. It -may- be that Mace's style best defeated Palpatine, but against Yoda's Ataru or Dooku's Makashi it might prove to be a disaster. Nothing is ever that straightforward. Well, except Whicket the Ewok versus the Death Star. THAT is a bit one-sided.

Second verse, bullshit like the first. You mistyped and said it was Palpatine versus Dooku, but I'll just chalk that up to poor typing skillz, yo. First off, no one and nothing ever ever said that the three Jedi masters Palpatine killed were even anywhere close to the best. About a year or two into the Clone Wars, Kit Fisto was about equal to Obi-Wan Kenobi. However, Kit's basic style never allowed him the defense and potential that Obi's did, thus Obi-Wan by ROTS is amazing while Kit Fisto would probably die against Anakin or Grievous. As for Dooku trying ALL his tricks and going all out on Yoda in AOTC, this is bullshit and unfounded.

Yes, Dooku fights Yoda. And his own insecurities and reluctance to slay the old Jedi master truly stay his hand, along with the fact that two jedi padawans and two jedi knights (Obi-Wan and Anakin Skywalker) broke into his mansion, with the Republic no doubt on their heels. Again, Dooku was no fool and took the easy way out. I'd like to point out that at this point Dooku was heavily conflicted with love for his old master and fear of his new master. Dooku was under the illusion that he could not be redeemed and that the dark side would be the end of him should he try. Thus, he made his choice and remained a Sith. And if the dark side energies -clearly- gave Dooku an advantage, than Assajj Ventress should have been confident enough to take on Anakin and Obi-Wan, seeing as she just killed two jedi masters that day.

Originally posted by Darth_Janus
Nothing is ever that straightforward. Well, except Whicket the Ewok versus the Death Star. THAT is a bit one-sided.

Go Whicket! JK.

I agree with what Janus said. He starting to follow my lead more everyday. JK. Except for the part about agreeing with him.

lol... roit.

Wiket winsss!!! lol11!!1!

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Go Whicket! JK.

I agree with what Janus said. He starting to follow my lead more everyday. JK. Except for the part about agreeing with him.

jk? JK!? Whicket would lose to the Death Star? Whata re you on? He met LUKE SKYWALER, the God of the Force! Luke's power is so great that transfers to othjers, which is the only reason that Padme was the Chosen One! DUH!! That means Whicket would own with his Skywalker skillz!!

. . . .

lmao... The hierarchy goes like this...

Padme Nekkid>Whicket>TPM Annie>Darth Binks>That one old guy in the intro of ANH with crazy ass sideburns

✅

Thou hath mastered the art of rating. I conmgratulte thee on thy success. BUt still, Luke=Everyone PWN3deth.

No one atchally has seen dookus full power as he couldnt relli do it to anakin in Ep III As the emp told him not to kill him

Man, dooku would use the force to move his lightsaber around in the air, and still own anakin. NO HANDS!

We never really finished this. and i still want to see who you guys would say win

I am now under the belief that Makashi is weak against forms that use a lot of brute strength. Mace uses the two brute forms, five and seven. I am going to give this to Mace. Dooku is better overall for fighting Jedi, but Mace would win this fight because of a form advantage.

Glentract, that is a damn stupid observation. Anakin Skywalker had more brute strength then Obi-Wan or Dooku even as of AOTC, and he still got served. Do you have anything to back this up, or is this another bout of Glentract mind changing? Not to be an ass, because I don't have anything against you... but prove up man!

Edited
LJ stole what i wanted to say

anyway Janus, your usually right, who do you reckon?

Read the ROTS novel. I know you don't like it, but it is as canon as any other book. The Dooku fight.

Pg. "Skywalker's Shien ready-stance had been a ruse, as had the ataro gymnastics; the boy was a Djem So stylist, and as fine a one as Dooku had ever seen. His own elegant Makasi simply didn't generate the kinetic power to meet Djem So head-to-head."

The rots novel is as un cannon as SW books can get... It directly contradicts the movies, its an authors view on an unfinished product. Whatever is said in there can not be taken as a truth.

None of you have shown anything to back it down with.

To do what?

Destroy the book? It contradicts the movies, its not cannon its false you can't use it as a source pure and simple.

Makashi being weak against people with pshyical power? There is no evidence of that at all. How could Dooku have ever won from Mace in the first place? How could he have taken out Obi Wan and Anakin in AOTC? And how could he have been better in ROTS? His style isn't weak against people that hit hard, there is absolutely no evidence for it at all.

Well, if you go by the novelization, it even says Dooku wanted to draw Anakin towards the dark side, and have Sidious do the rest. Suspicious, isn't it?

Ok we have established that the books maybe wrong but who would win this fight? I think it would be mace however i could be swayed another way?