Originally posted by Veneficus
OMFG...Sidious as the best? Anakin second? Dooku third!?...Dear God help this wayward fanboy.
errrr....actually its Yoda first, i dont know, maybe i didnt make it clear enough by putting the number one and then yoda beside it...
anyways, yes, anakin beats dooku, dooku is far better then most everyone else so...i dont see much of a problem here.
as for sidious, he was about equal to Yoda and to say that Yoda was not the best is utterly retarded...
(btw, i dont think mace actually should have/ did beat palpatine just so you know)
Where is this craze coming from?
*Listens to 1st Infantry's "It's A Craze."
Dooku let Anakin win. He was told by Sidious to let him win. Fact. The only two people said to ever take Windu were Dooku and Yoda, and Dooku took him while Mace was a padawan/knight. Fact.
BTW I asked for top 10 JEDI duelists. Sidious shouldn't be on that list, neither should Dooku.
Originally posted by Se7in
Where is this craze coming from?*Listens to 1st Infantry's "It's A Craze."
Dooku let Anakin win. He was told by Sidious to let him win. Fact. The only two people said to ever take Windu were Dooku and Yoda, and Dooku took him while Mace was a padawan/knight. Fact.
BTW I asked for top 10 JEDI duelists. Sidious shouldn't be on that list, neither should Dooku.
ahh, true...
so then its:
1. Yoda
2. Anakin
3. Windu
4. Obi-Wan
5. Qui-Gon
as for the "dooku let anakin win" i see nothing to prove that in the movie. its hardly a 'fact' sorry...
as for the only people beating windu, sure fine. so dooku beat him. and so did yoda. if its fact as you said then thats that. (oh i know ur gonna say that but he hadent developed form 7 etc. etc.) never the less dooku surley imporoved greatly as well (and form II is made for duelling) and yoda's had 800 years saber expericnace, theres no way windu can top that. its not possible.
and i just think personally and from what i've seen that anakin would beat windu.
as for the "dooku let anakin win" i see nothing to prove that in the movie. its hardly a 'fact' sorry...[/QUOTE]
This is an EU forum. We look beyond the movies and the ignorance of traditional fans like you.
as for the only people beating windu, sure fine. so dooku beat him. and so did yoda. if its fact as you said then thats that. (oh i know ur gonna say that but he hadent developed form 7 etc. etc.) never the less dooku surley imporoved greatly as well (and form II is made for duelling) and yoda's had 800 years saber expericnace, theres no way windu can top that. its not possible.[/QUOTE]
Dooku was already ~45 years old. Mace was like 15. It doesn't matter what the form was, Dooku was far more expeinced at that time. Mace still hadn't learned much, it was the more basic Jedi powers, while Dooku had been a Master for ~20 years.
and i just think personally and from what i've seen that anakin would beat windu. [/QUOTE]
If you can't provide reasonable proof for this, then say what you think and move on until you find reasonable proof.
Originally posted by ((The_Anomaly))
ahh, true...so then its:
1. Yoda
2. Anakin
3. Windu
4. Obi-Wan
5. Qui-Gonas for the "dooku let anakin win" i see nothing to prove that in the movie. its hardly a 'fact' sorry...
as for the only people beating windu, sure fine. so dooku beat him. and so did yoda. if its fact as you said then thats that. (oh i know ur gonna say that but he hadent developed form 7 etc. etc.) never the less dooku surley imporoved greatly as well (and form II is made for duelling) and yoda's had 800 years saber expericnace, theres no way windu can top that. its not possible.
and i just think personally and from what i've seen that anakin would beat windu.
Let's go by the movies. Okay, that means Obi should now be 2, and by your logic, since Anakin is better than Mace, Mace becomes 4th.
Anakin is the best guys. He SURVIVED it all. The force was strong enough with him that he didn't need to be the most experienced swordsman, (although naturally talented he was at it) he just predicted their moves through the force and fought better.
Obi-Wan beat Anakin because he knew him well. He was also powerful enough to predict someone's moves, plus being defensive, plus knowing his apprentice so well. Anakin was foolish enough to run into Obi-Wan's blade in the end.
And yes, I do belive that Anakin could beat Mace as well. Anakin is superior in the force, and with the right determination, he could very well take him.
Don't get me started with Yoda...I'm done for now.
Originally posted by ((The_Anomaly))
ahh, true...so then its:
1. Yoda
2. Anakin
3. Windu
4. Obi-Wan
5. Qui-Gonas for the "dooku let anakin win" i see nothing to prove that in the movie. its hardly a 'fact' sorry...
as for the only people beating windu, sure fine. so dooku beat him. and so did yoda. if its fact as you said then thats that. (oh i know ur gonna say that but he hadent developed form 7 etc. etc.) never the less dooku surley imporoved greatly as well (and form II is made for duelling) and yoda's had 800 years saber expericnace, theres no way windu can top that. its not possible.
and i just think personally and from what i've seen that anakin would beat windu.
OH MY F*CKING GOD!
ACK!
*Has a Seizure*
1. Yoda
2. Mace
3. Obi-Wan
4. Anakin
5. Plo Koon
6. Cin Drallig
7. Luminara
8. Kit Fisto
9. Saesee Tiin
10. Agen Kolar
I dont care what u say that's what i think
If u want me to go on...
11. Ki-Adi-Mundi
12. Shaak Ti
13. Qui-Gon (at the time he dueled Maul)
14. Yarael Poof
15. Bastila Shan
16. Aayla Secura (even if her clones killed her with a snap of their fingers, she still beat Aurra Sing)
Oh and i forgot to put Sora Bulq and Quinlan Vos somewhere in my lists
The REAL list yo!
1. Yoda
2. Emperor
3. Vader
4. Duku (Schools Obi won twice)
5. Ben Kenobi
6. Luke James Skywalker
7. Mace
8. Darth Maul
9. Qui-gon
10. Kit Fisto
Anybody who disagrees obviously knows nothing about star wars. I have viewed each movie over 59 times. Don't even think you know more than me. I actually went to school with george lucas and gave him the idea of the lightsaber...except I called it a lazer knife.