Top 10 Jedi Duelists of the PT Era

heres what i think

yoda
dooku
mace
depa
shaak-ti
cin
obi-wan
anikin
luminara
Vos

No order

1.shaak ti
2.quinlan vos
3.obi-wan
4Dooku
5Anakin
6.Qui Gon
7.Aayla Secura
8.sora Bulq
9.yoda
10.mace windu

if you're going to revive a thread that's been dead for nearly 3 years, then you should probably at least adhere to the rules and put them in order.

1: Mace Windu
2: Yoda
3: Obi-Wan
4: Anakin
5: Kit Fisto
6: Cin Drallig
7: Luminara Unduli
8: Depa Bililba
9: Quinlan Vos
10: Sora Bulq

Cant beat SLJ 😛

the dumb emperor would have died if anakin wouldnt have steeped in mace could have taken them both it is just that his concentrain was broken so the emperor had a chance but windu beats them

Originally posted by master monkey
the dumb emperor would have died if anakin wouldnt have steeped in mace could have taken them both it is just that his concentrain was broken so the emperor had a chance but windu beats them

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
if you're going to revive a thread that's been dead for nearly 3 years, then you should probably at least adhere to the rules and put them in order.

Alright than

1.Windu
2.Yoda
3.Kenobi
4.Skywalker
5.Dooku
6.Jinn
7.Drallig
8.Vos
9.Bulq
10.Ti

Mace is shit. 😐

That whole list is shit.

Why has Mace got such high votes? His fight was sloooooooooooooooooow.

Yoda
Maul
Qui-Gon
Sidious
Anakin
Grevious
Obi-Wan
Dooku
Plo Koon
Ki-Adi-Mundi

Mace Windu
Obi-wan Kenobi
Yoda
Sora Bulq
Sidious
Dooku
Anakin
Quilan Vos
Depa Billaba
Qui-Gon

As far as the top 10 duelists go (in order):

1. Yoda/Sidious
2. Mace Windu
3. Anakin Skywalker
4. Count Dooku
6. Obi-Wan Kenobi
7. Darth Maul
8. General Grievous

I'm undecided about the rest.

I am gonna add sith in their as well because everyone else is

1.Yoda
2.Sidious
3.Mace
4.Anakin
5.Dooku
6.Obi-Wan
7.General Grievous
8.Maul
9.Asaj Ventress
10.Kit Fisto

Right, I forgot about Asajj Ventress. She'll probably come one rank before Maul.

Uh, Maul almost killed Sidious. Ventress only almost killed OB1. I'd say Maul is ahead of her.

I don't think the 'he almost killed Sidious' argument is very valid, but fine. In Obsession (6 months before the events of ROTS, I believe), Ventress gave Anakin a very hard time. I'd like to see how Maul would fare against Anakin by then.

Why not valid? Just curious.

I don't know, I think Maul would be a hand full for Anakin because 1, he's just as aggressive, if not more. Now I know that aggressiveness doesn't equal skill, but I don't think that anyone would doubt the skill of "one of the deadliest Sith apprentices ever."

Actually, I think it is quite close. Both are, in my book, up there in the top 10, and only being separated by a mere rank. Another point on favour of Maul: he was worthy of being apprenticed by Sidious, while Ventress was a mere tool. But, he already had Dooku, of course. Would Sidious have still chosen Maul if in TPM Ventress was as strong as she was in Obsession? That is something we will never know.

I'd say they are almost equally matched, maybe you're right, and Maul is just slightly above her.

I don't know if she was as... "ruthless" as Maul, so to speak. I know she was a dark Jedi and all that, but from what I've read and heard about Maul, he'd kill anyone at the drop of a hat and was just filled with tenacity. But while they might be close, I'd still put Maul above her.

I would say the top 3 are yoda, obi wan and mace windu, not sure about the others.