Magneto vs The Hulk

Started by Wynndar82 pages

they r refering to comic books where he doesnt need the iron injection trick man...it is assumed we dont refer to movie events in the versus forum...I still want to see what these guys have to say about my Jack of Hearts evidence

Originally posted by picoico
Here's how it happens. Magento starts the fight. Hulk picks up rock or tree. Hulk smashes. Magneto dies. Period. I understand how a magnetic shield will hold up against energy blasts...but matter that isn't affected by electro-magnatism? He has no chance.

I think it blocks everything. Just 'cause.

Nobody's answered me about if Magneto gets feedback or not when something overwhelms him.

Originally posted by Swanky-Tuna
I think it blocks everything. Just 'cause.

Nobody's answered me about if Magneto gets feedback or not when something overwhelms him.

Well, then he's obviously not Magneto anymore, he's Justcauseto.

No, rock hits magneto. Hulk smash. Unless magneto manages to create a rail gun effect and vaporize said rock before it hits him. Bah, hulk eventually smash. So long as mags doesn't use near-light velocity projectiles to vaporize hulk. :-)

If I were a writer, I'd definitely not rely on mags "shielding" ability...but focus on his vast ability for offense beyond the stupid human-tricks. I mean, have the dude drop an iron rich meteor from space. Heheehhe....yeah....that's cool.

probably not, i would only think something being pressed against an electro-magnetic shield would eventually knock mag's back with alot of force....but i honestly dont know

Originally posted by Wynndar
and how was that supposed to convince anyone that Magneto is faster..If Hulk can catch Jack of Hearts he can certainly catch Mags...do ur research, do these people even know who Jack of hearts is?...he manged to hurt Tyrant!!! something Thanos, Morg, Silver Surfer, Terrax, Beta Ray Bill and Gladiator could not do combined...and ur still defending to a punk @ss x-men villain like magneto?

I told you like 4 times, Jack of hearts was flying AWAY from hulk, whereas magneto will just do a sideways movement... because he can move any direction he chooses. Then the girder in the spine, which no one can say wont work, because we all know damn well it will.

actually i dont think it would work, since missiles, which explode on impact havent pierced him...so imo i dont think the girder would do anything, except piss off the hulk, kind of like a cheap shot to the groin would piss off....just about anyone lol

i dont think it would do anything either...steel is like tissue paper to the hulk. at best hulk would get a paper cut and heal instantaneously. and the over come mags sheild with a breeze and flick magsy's head right off.

Originally posted by Nataku8188
Then the girder in the spine, which no one can say wont work, because we all know damn well it will.

I can't find much on Hulk's bones except for word of mouth saying it rivals adamantium, but Hulk's muscles and skin would probably be too durable to just hurl a girder at him and expect it to pierce like speargun though Wolverine's sweet tender neck.

yea do people understand that missiles that rip steal apart and blow up buildings dont penetrate Hulk's skin...why would a blunt girder do anything but tickle?...and by the way...for those people who know about comics....Wolverine's claws were originally unable to penetrate Hulk's skin in his first few encounters...from his first appearance to his encounter with Hulk in the tournament of champions.

You people forget that magneto can put hundreds of thousands of pounds of pressure on that one steel girder. Pfft.

I got lost on this battle pages ago, all this science shit is too much to keep up with.😐

X-men #blah blah blah: the death of a giant.

As magneto enjoys a warm day in the sun with his lover, Mystique, the two are attacked by a not so jolly green giant known as the hulk. The hulk jumps on Mystique and kills her instantly. An enraged Magneto decides to once again use a power he has used on rare occasions in the past, the ability to control the natural iron in someone's blood; he uses the fullest exent of his power to rip all the iron out of the hulk's hemoglobin and actually pull it through the pores in the giant's skin. The hulk, still being an organic being who needs an oxygen transport system and being unable to create matter to autotrophically make more iron, quickly dies a slow painful death. After Magneto uses his power to bury Mystique, he looks at the corpse of the green giant and smiles.

There, now that is in writing. It may not be good writing from a reputable source, but it is still in writing so it happened, and as soon as I hit submit reply it will be published. Here we go, get ready to witness the death of your beloved hulkster...

in the words of goerge clooney in welcome to collinwood "...you're an idiot"

that would mean that any damn fan fiction ever made would be "published" although when you hit that button it says "submit reply" not "submit to the printing press and it'll be a comic!"

as for mag's pulling the iron out of hulks body, i dont think people understand the strength of MISSILES (you know the things used in war to knock down a whole city or two) have hit the hulk everywhere, and not penetrate his skin (not just the little green skin you see on the outside, remember theres alot more layers to that) not to mention MUSCLE, you know the gamma radiated ones......its a comic book character, hulks hemoglobin wont be put into consideration, since technically gamma radiation would just kill you

and how would you be able to make this xmen, MAGNETO IS DEAD

btw if you were j/k, i didn't get the sarcasm since we're talking online

Originally posted by Nataku8188
How exactly does hulk do this when he's leaping through the air and getting a girder shoved through his spine from behind, per say?

Magneto can move faster then hulk can in the air, and he can easily drive a girder through his spine from behind.

As for him crushing Mjolnir, that was in a dream. The 250 ton mountain range was stupid to begin with, and the whole onsalught series was bullshit anyways. Since when does Juggernaut have the gem INSIDE of him? He doesn't. A lot of things that occured during the onslaught cycle are retarded, i mean if onslaught can physicly (And yes, it was physical, his fingers pierce juggernaut's flesh) tear out a gem that isn't even there... then we know its bullshit.

have you seen what happens when Hulk gets hit by a steel girder or any big metal object other than Wolvie's claws?

it bends. Have you ever seen Hulk impaled by any metal object? No.

That girder would even break his skin...all it would do is hit him from behind and knock him out of air....far from an incapacitating blow.

It did not pierce his flesh, he was not bleeding, and where exactly did Onslaught come from when that happened? Wasn't he like under the X-Mansion with Jean Grey?

JuggFan puts up the same arguement about the crystal getting ripped from his body, but NO ONE mentions how ambiguous the whole scene is. It is NOT clear whether or not they ment that as a mental attack or a physical attack.

Personally, I believe what he did was rip the EMBODIMENT of the crystal from Juggernaut. it is a VERY unclear scene but what is more likely to scare Juggs...something in real life....or in his head?

I do think Mags would win. But yeah the last post was just sarcasm. sorry for the confusion. LOL

Girder?!?! Flinging metal objects? Come on folks, doesn't ANYONE know what a rail gun is? Do a bit of surfing....

For the record, it is said that Hulk can't survive a nuclear blast at ground zero.

Hulk HAS been torn to shreds by a villan with an adamantium suit of armor...can't remember his name. He has an incredible healing factor. n his first tussles with wolvie, they weren't allowed to show blood and guts in that kind of comic, so they just made his skin elastic enough that wolvie couldn't pierce it.

actually they re-made the comic and logan still could'nt pierce hulks skin

a nuclear blast at ground zero is differing from this battle, magneto doesnt have the power of nuclear blasts

who's the villain with the adamantium armor, cyber??

Originally posted by turboman1691
I do think Mags would win. But yeah the last post was just sarcasm. sorry for the confusion. LOL

lol, my mistake

missles do not hurt hulk because they are only coming in with so much momentum (speed + weight). Mags can move somthing MUCH MUCH MUCH heavier at speeds that are MUCH MUCH MUCH faster.

Originally posted by Nataku8188
I told you like 4 times, Jack of hearts was flying AWAY from hulk, whereas magneto will just do a sideways movement... because he can move any direction he chooses. Then the girder in the spine, which no one can say wont work, because we all know damn well it will.

Jack of Hearts is far more capable of flying sideways, or any direction, considering he has exceptionally impressive flying abilities...Ive never seen magneto fly at near light speeds...even on earth magneto has mediocre flying abilities...JOH was far more capable at manuevering than magneto but Hulk still caught him...why do u keep on drawing out your own circumstances of the fight, saying what u think would happen in a fight: "magneto would just fly sideways"...what makes u think he is capable of it...do u notice how all the people who are favoring the Hulk keep refering to actual comic events...however there isnt one single example from a comic book that would lead anyone to believe Magneto could take the Hulk...