I want to say Mags would win really badly, and I'm sure in most comics, if they were to meet, Mags would win.
But i don't think he could incapacitate the Hulk like Juggernaut did. It's be sooooo fun to watch him drop oil tankers and buildings on Hulk, but in the end, he's basically human.
If Hulk so much as gets a hand on him.....bye Magneto.
yep...the reason Hulk doesnt **** with magneto, as someone put it earlier, because if he did, magneto would be dead....and there would be a lot of unhappy x-men fans...they also said something about Cable being a real problem for Magneto rather than the Hulk...what the hell are they talking about...Last time Cable ran into the Hulk he basically ran for his life for the entire issue....then with the rest of the x-men, tried to scramble for a way to survive...Hulk crushes mags...and any other x-men that want any too
Muahaha! I'm back for another round today bitches!
What Manjaro said is correct. We simply have not seen a writer who has had the brains to work Magneto to his potential. In fact, we haven't had a decent writer put on Mags YET. Case in point: Magneto can lift 30,000 tons with his powers, yet a man MADE OF METAL at only class 100 broke free of his hold? What kind of stupid ass shit is that?? It's just...illogical.
Anyway, Magneto indeed controls the entire magnetic specturm AND related energies. Magneto CAN uproot a whole forest, and lift a body of water. In fact, he CAN rip a human apart at their very molecular seams, seeing that most of our bodies have a slight polarization. Why hasn't it been done? Because the writers are..."scientifically impaired".
To that guy who said that Hulk was more powerful than Magneto because of gamma radiation: You're an idiot. Hulk cannot channel the radiation in any way, other than brute strength. So, even if it was more powerful, Hulk can't use the power for anything more than a punch.
Hulk couldn't get close enough to Magneto to do anything, this is why Cable is a greater threat. I'm talking about current Cable, with his ****ing god-like telekinesis. The X-Men aren't even an issue, they are scared shitless of Magneto, and they all know, with the exception of Phoenix and Prof. X,(MAYBE Storm. Very big maybe.) that he'd rape them.
every power has its limits, even magneto's. just because it is possible for him to do something doesn't mean he is capable of doing it. take for example that ripping humans apart by molecule theory. what if he has the power to do it but isn't capable of doing it because there are other complications. like maybe its more complicated than simply ripping the molecules apart. possibly you might need to be knowledgeable in the human anatomy before you are able to do something like that.
anyway, even if he could do that, the question stands if he is powerful enuf to rip hulk apart. with the type of durability hulk has in his cells, it would be awfullly hard to rip him apart.
Im not saying they should do it for every storyarc, but for a good 6-12 issues they should have a story where Magneto unleashes everything he is capable of. Just once. That would be fan-****ing-tastic. And it would solve alot of these vs. matchups. Apparently, people can't use logic to come to a reasonable conclusion, and they need "but he did this so he is more powerfull!11!!one!!1".
Im not arguing that magneto has those capabilities, or trying to define his powers...he controls all electromagnetism and can use this with great diversity...however, there is a limit to how much power he can use...if his powers were just totally inexhaustable he would just be moving stars across galaxies like molecule man...however, if he tried using his powers to a fraction of that degree he would lack the endurance and strength to accomplish it...Hulk on the other hand has never shown a limit to his strength...he doesnt even show strain...but when magneto accomplishes a powerful display of magnetic manipulation he is certainly strained...he has a limit to how much power he can command...although i will say there is almost no limit to what his actual powers can do
Hulk still wins IMO
i am just saying that what gives hulk his superstrangth is on an atomic level, just as mag's mutant powers are. so mad could never tear apart the hulk on a molecular level, and also...the fact that hulk has inapplicaple brute strength gives him the upper hand. the only thing mag could try is to hold hulk forever in space, in which mag will get tired and hulk will rip him apart. mag could never hope to rip apart hulk' flesh via the iron in his blood. hulk's blood is stronger than mag's power. i think the hulk can break thor's hammer given enough time. hulk and cap ama\erica are the only two beings in the marvel universe other than thor to be able to weild it. there is no metal in marvel's univers that is stronger than hulk, or hulk wouldnt be such a threat to the universe like how he was.
magneto and havock together could beat the hulk though.
Magneto doesn't have to hold him forever, and Magneto doesn't even need to use metal.
You know that magnetic force feild he uses to protect himself? Yea, he can make that around anyone. Encasing Hulk, and flinging him a few thousand miles away constitues a victory for one match.
This is only one match right? Or is someone going to change it to best 2 out of 3 to better their argument?
I'm going to go ahead an argue those capabilities. What we have here is not poor writing that hasn't unleashed "Magneto's True Power"
What we have is fanboyism. Yes, i went ahead and said it....Fanboyism.
Magneto doesn't do stuff like uproot whole forests or raise lakes...BECAUSE HE CAN'T DO IT! If he could do it...he would do it.
Quit making up powers for the freaking guy just because you want to win this arguement. This is comic discussion, not magnetic theory.
It's not about IFs, WOULDs, and COULDs....it's what he CAN DO and CAN'T DO. And he can't stop the Hulk.
magneto would never last past one match with hulk. 1st of all, that stupid force feild thing of magneto's; a) mag cant keep that up for ever and would get tired, and yes magneto can drain his powers if he uses too much, other wise he would have already enslaved humans. and b) hulk is so strong that eventually he would break free of the stupid force feild, and then what is mag gonna do? thats right,...run.
hulk connot breath in space,....but he can hold his breath all day. magneto cannot hold his breath in outter space either. and eventually the oxygen inside his force feild would run out if ever in space in extended periods of time.
yes great idea, and then hulk would swim trough space till he gets on earth, and of course space pressure would not kill him because he is the hulk, and the fact that in space the temperature is very cold, would not make any diference because HE IS THE HULK.
you are forgeting we have a genius fighting a retarded.