dumbledore is not dead

*sighs in utter annoyance*

As much as i wish Dumbledore hadn't died, he did. Look, it was just good storytelling to kill off Dumbledore, and if she brings him back...honestly, it would be breaking the rules JK Rowling has set in the world. Dumbledore himself said that no spell could bring back the dead. Honestly, I would be very disappointed in JK Rowling's abilities if it turned out that Dumbledore wasn't REALLY dead, he was just FAKIN' it, so everything is fine and now Harry can go back to school and *yawn* Dumbledore the great protects Harry again. I'm sorry, but that would just suck, in my opinion.

But hey, it's fun to pretend 😊

face it, he IS dead

How can anyone say other wise?

If JK says he is, he is. I mean she wouldn't lie.

They'res no doubt about it that dumbledore is dead..I know he is ..i just don't wan to beleive it ..just like I think harry is a horcrux.

Originally posted by dumbyaintdead
I have a ton of proof suggesting Dumbledore faked his death. i want to know if i am wrong and the other proof other people have about this situation.

Dumbledore is NOT dead.
the Avada does not send you flying back into the air.
snape was saying avada kedavra and didnt mean it. REMEMBER WHAT MOODY SAYS, AND BELLATRIX, YOU NEED TO MEAN THEM. but he was nonverbally saying something else, thats why dumbledore flew back.
Thats why nonverbal spells were mentioned so much in this book.
Snape looked angry because he didnt want to hurt dumbledore when he sent him flying back.,
Hagrid heard them arguing that snape didnt want to do somthing but Dumby said he had to.
about the unbreakable vow, who said there wasnt a time limit.
he did everything he could to "help" draco but he wouldnt let snape help him.
he obviously lied to narcissa and bellatrix after he looked into her mind since it was all she could think about and pretended voldy told him about the plan.

reply your comments

Wow i don't think you have accepted him dying but maybe he did NOT die

Maybe you want to go and read this:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=371064&pagenumber=6#post5447215

And after you've done that you can tell me again that DD is dead. And by the way: You really thing JKR would tell people if she's going to make DD come back ? There's simply no way she can avoid that question because giving an other comment than "He's dead." would mean that it would be clear that he will return. And I bet he will do that.

im sorry,but every post in here that has suggested dumbledore is alive, is a stupid post. Just get over it. The only reason gandalf from lord of the ringd came back to life is because it represented jesus christ. So shut up and get over the fact that Dumbledore is dead. If he had lived he would have been holding harry back by protecting him. Sheesh

i'm not taking a stand on whether or not i think dumbledore is truly gone or not. however, i happened upon this site --> dumbledoreisnotdead.com that gives good evidence to suggest that he may very well be alive. this site also acknowledges unanswered questions. take it for what it is or however you will. in any case, it is well thought out, with quotations and citations, and is well written. enjoy. 😄

DUMBLEDOREISNOTDEAD.COM <--check it ooooout. xP

Originally posted by allofyousuckkk

But the vow that Snape made was to help Draco, it didn't say anything else. Draco obviously didn't want to kill Dumbledor so maybe the way that Snape helped Draco, was for him not to have to do that.
I just don't think it was that simple. Dumbledor was a great wizard, he can't of just died like that

okay lets take this from the top.
Dumbldore is dead because snape killed him, and he killed dumbldore on dumbldores orders. it partly had to do with the unbrakable vow too.
dumbldore knows that when the final battle comes he has prepared harry well, he has his friends along with the order of the pheonix to help him with the death eaters, and dumbldore also knows harry needs to confront voldemort alone, and when harry finishes with the horcrux's he will be more adept in his magical skills than he was before.
it's not a matter if harry keeps losing the ones he loves, dumbldore is old and even he slips once and a while, im sure he didnt plan on dieing as soon as he did, but he knew snape would do his job as instructed.
know that harry stands with his friends and the order harry knows he cant rely on anyone anymore, he need to fight the battle himself as leader.
harry is very powerful and has been told so by dumbldore, harry has the power to love, and thats why he will defeat voldemort, because i really doubt voldemort thinks harry is anywere near his power...how very wrong he is....
i personally dont think sirius or dumbldore will come back but harry might find a way to commune with them through a magical means, it doesnt make sense that there deaths leave alot of questions.

Snape is very much well alive. Which means Dumbledore is dead.

we dont really know if snape is alive or not.

I believe dumby is not dead too. About Dumby teleporting from the tomb i dont think he even needs to because he is not there at all. They do not mention Dumbys body anywhere in the burial part. Only they say Hagrid is carrying a green cloth with stars and they all think its dumbys body wrapped in it but its not.

Originally posted by Thorinn
okay lets take this from the top.
Dumbldore is dead because snape killed him, and he killed dumbldore on dumbldores orders. it partly had to do with the unbrakable vow too.
dumbldore knows that when the final battle comes he has prepared harry well, he has his friends along with the order of the pheonix to help him with the death eaters, and dumbldore also knows harry needs to confront voldemort alone, and when harry finishes with the horcrux's he will be more adept in his magical skills than he was before.
it's not a matter if harry keeps losing the ones he loves, dumbldore is old and even he slips once and a while, im sure he didnt plan on dieing as soon as he did, but he knew snape would do his job as instructed.
know that harry stands with his friends and the order harry knows he cant rely on anyone anymore, he need to fight the battle himself as leader.
harry is very powerful and has been told so by dumbldore, harry has the power to love, and thats why he will defeat voldemort, because i really doubt voldemort thinks harry is anywere near his power...how very wrong he is....
i personally dont think sirius or dumbldore will come back but harry might find a way to commune with them through a magical means, it doesnt make sense that there deaths leave alot of questions.

Well, thats one part of the coin. But on the other side I, like many others beleive that Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore is alife, bacause there are so many things that make us beleive so. And knowing Jo, I do not beleive she will make such mistakes ...

Dumbledore is DEAD no matter how much we want him to come back. i myself loved dumbledore a lot, and i nearly cried when i found out he died. no matter how much i want him to come back, I dont think he is

Its funny. People say he is not dead because they just don't want him dead. Like I little kid getting far in a game and then getting a game over, not wanting it to be over and keep going. Get over peoples. He is dead. Be happy.

Despite your realism Phantom, the time will tell us who was right, it migh however be the case as you point, but definetelly it would be interesting once the 7 book is out to come back and re-read what we though will see