dumbledore is not dead

Originally posted by Unicor777
Despite your realism Phantom, the time will tell us who was right, it migh however be the case as you point, but definetelly it would be interesting once the 7 book is out to come back and re-read what we though will see

dumbledore is still alive.in 6th book it said a phoinex apeared in the sky only harry could see it.so he probally transformed into a phoinex.this is my guess he is looking for sirus to save harry from voldemort in their last duel.

there are also many other points, check the website www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com, it contains a lot of "evidence", many of whom are related to phoenix

Originally posted by springboy34
dumbledore is still alive.in 6th book it said a phoinex apeared in the sky only harry could see it.so he probally transformed into a phoinex.this is my guess he is looking for sirus to save harry from voldemort in their last duel.

Originally posted by The Phantom
Umm..... no. One, SIRIUS! Dammit your spelling is driving me nuts. Two, Sirius is as dead as Dumbledore.... even deader if DD is alive. So.... yea. Umm.... did anyone think the Phoenix could be... shit I don't remember how to... wait I have the book hold on.... screw it I"m not going through all the pages. Fawkes I believe it is spelled. I dunno. Phoenixes are everywhere. It could have been some random one.

Originally posted by springboy34
Sirius acualy went it to a well that takes him to a diffrent world.and forgot about my guess DD saving surius, he is in a world that he can't escape.it said that in 5th book.

Originally posted by The Phantom
.... *slaps uncontrollably*

Originally posted by springboy34
what do you mean uncontorllably slaps?

have you ever read the 6th book or 5th book of Harry Potter phantom?

Originally posted by springboy34
have you ever read the 6th book or 5th book of Harry Potter phantom?

i think ur right about dumbledore's "death".the killing curse doesn't send u flying because in the 4th movie and book Cedric just falls over.

Dumbledore is dead. JKR has confirmed that both DUmbledore and Sirius are dead. Stop speculating about this inane garbage, and get a POSSIBLE theory.

Originally posted by Borbarad
Maybe you want to go and read this:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=371064&pagenumber=6#post5447215

And after you've done that you can tell me again that DD is dead. And by the way: You really thing JKR would tell people if she's going to make DD come back ? There's simply no way she can avoid that question because giving an other comment than "He's dead." would mean that it would be clear that he will return. And I bet he will do that.

I gaurentee (sp?) that Dumbledore is 100% dead. He isn't alive. JKR has stated that Dumbledore is most definately dead. SHe killed him to make sure that Harry was the only Hero (or failed Hero, I dunno.)

I also find it funny that people cried over DD death. IT'S A FICTIONAL BOOK PEOPLE!

go hpfanizzledizzl u rock an i totally agree wid ya

Thanks Denniz

I think the real question is did Dumbledore plan his own death???? 🙂

Shit.... thought. I don't know if this was in the book but I know it was in the movie.... Snape said in book one the movie (maybe in the book, don't remember) that he can brew a potion that could "put a stopper to death." THE entire thing was planned! THis was just between DD and Snape. Snape brewed the potion and filled the bowl DD drank from with it, with DD knowing. Now, it either hurts in when drinking it or DD did some great acting, I dunno anything on the potion. So the spell that would have killed him, didn't because of the potion, and thus the fall as well.... course, that is just a theory.

Sorry, I now think DD is alive. (I always thought Snape was good)

Originally posted by The Phantom
Shit.... thought. I don't know if this was in the book but I know it was in the movie.... Snape said in book one the movie (maybe in the book, don't remember) that he can brew a potion that could "put a stopper to death." THE entire thing was planned! THis was just between DD and Snape. Snape brewed the potion and filled the bowl DD drank from with it, with DD knowing. Now, it either hurts in when drinking it or DD did some great acting, I dunno anything on the potion. So the spell that would have killed him, didn't because of the potion, and thus the fall as well.... course, that is just a theory.

Sorry, I now think DD is alive. (I always thought Snape was good)

✅

http://www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com/dumbledoreclues.html

http://www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com/snapeclues.html

Dumbledore is dead.

Originally posted by willRules
✅

http://www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com/dumbledoreclues.html

http://www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com/snapeclues.html

Originally posted by hpfanizzledizzl
Dumbledore is dead.