Quite possibly the most mind blowing theory ever...

Originally posted by iluvsirius
if you still see Harry Potter as a childs book well then weve got serious problems...it stopped being a childs book since i think book 4...and if he took out the dark lord when he went to invite him to hogwarts well it would be REALLY WEIRD that he just killed a kid in an orphanage! things have to pass for destiny to be fulfilled it could be tampered with but not extremely changed cause then history will change...

yes it is a childs book. jk wrote them to be a childs books.
also it wouldent be weerd if you took him out as a child, hello if you could go back and kill/capture one person in order to save countless friends, and family members.. you would do it would you not??? you would not nessesaraly have to kill the kid ether.. you could capture him... or there are even other possibilities.,.. the point is if DD was Ron but older, DD would know what the dark lord was up to... DD would have know when rons dad got hurt in the ministry in the 5th book... he would have know harrys name was going to come out of the goblet... he would have ben able to save harry... i think its just a vary smart wizard.. who knows what he is doing. And also he would have know what happend when the girl got cursed in the 6th book... and he would have know where the troll was in the 1st book... think about it.

this theory is impossible, JKR has already said it herself.

and lets say for example it is possible They left out Dumbledore's Brother How would they explain him?

Although this is impossible its the 'most mind-blowing' theory I have seen, and unless someone presents me with a better one I will hold that view...

You have a point there. It is "mind blowing." The fact that somebody sat and thought about all of that, finding everything and rereading the books over and over to come up with that is indeed 'mind blowing.' Refreshing even and also very scary.

ron is not dumble dore from the future or anything jk said that herself go to jkrowling.com and look it up

wow it kinda makes sence but how can 2 ppl be 1 thats like impossible isn,t it , it was really interesting n maybe ron n dd do have sum relationship ....................maybe there related

Originally posted by sammii
wow it kinda makes sence but how can 2 ppl be 1 thats like impossible isn,t it , it was really interesting n maybe ron n dd do have sum relationship ....................maybe there related

Ron's Aberforth!

Well, actually, Aberforth's the barman in the hogs Head but... and he doesnt smell of goats...

Originally posted by Knightfall93
Well, actually, Aberforth's the barman in the hogs Head but... and he doesnt smell of goats...

Originally posted by The Phantom
... Ok. Obviously you didn't read the entire thing. They can both be the same person by Time Turners or something. But this idea is really destroyed witht he Time Turners in book 5.

i never said the two were the same infact i said it was impossible

Originally posted by sammii
i never said the two were the same infact i said it was impossible