Luke vs. Anikin

Luke and Anikin are both very strong and the main characters. So who do you think will win?

What time anakin vs. what time luke? would it be fair ROTS Anakin vs. A New Hope Luke?

Who cares as long as it isn't TPM Anakin, Anakin wins against any Luke.

Whatta 'bout ROTS Anakin vs. ROTJ Luke?

Wait..wait...yep, Anakin gets his sons ass kicked.

Then it would be anakin

Bloody hell, xyz, give us more detail, learn to spell your fighter's name right, and give us more detail.

If we go by GL quotes over movies, ROTJ Luke is better than ROTS Anakin by a good margin.

If we go by GL quotes the universe will be destroyed. AOTC Anakin would still pwn RoTJ Luke.

Do you seriously think that ROTJ Luke would lose to AOTC Anakin?

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Do you seriously think that ROTJ Luke would lose to AOTC Anakin?

Well he might... AOTC Anakin may have been a fool but he did know how to wield a lightsaber and based on the movies alone far better then Luke could even dream off at that time. At that time all Anakin had done was more impressive then what Luke had done anyways. And he was beter then many Jedi in the arena that did die.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Do you seriously think that ROTJ Luke would lose to AOTC Anakin?

most ppl think ROTJ Luke sucks because the special effects werent as good as nowadays. Of course he would pwn AOTC ANakin

Well ROTJ Luke did beat Vader, if Vader let him win is arguable, anyway Vader was more powerful than AOTC Anakin so if it's AOTC Anakin vs ROTJ Luke I think Luke would win. ROTS Anakin would probably kill him though.

I am a full hearted beliver that Luke was crazy good by ROTJ. More powerful than ROTS Anakin, but it is close. Who do you hink is a better pilot?

Hmm good question, both were very skilled pilots though I think Luke got more time to practise his skills (age near of 20) while Anakin only did it for around 7 years, then focused more on his jedi skills than pilot skills. So I'll say Luke by an inch. Not that Anakin wasent traning piloting anymore, just that he didn't do it as much as he did as a kid.

ROTJ Luke >>>> AOTC or ROTS Anakin???

LMFAO!

Put the bottle down, you're cut off. If you can't see for yourself that Anakin was superior to ROTJ Luke, you are obviously drunk, high, or in denial.

Are you serious? What did Luke ever fly until he reached 20? Nothing really... Anakin had far more piloting skills and experience by that time.

He had far more everything. I really don't get the idea that ROTJ Luke is better than Anakin. It's silly, really.

Originally posted by xyz jedi
Luke and Anikin are both very strong and the main characters. So who do you think will win?

Hmm...let's see.

Guy with the ugliest hair cut ever seen in a SW movie having some weeks of force training under Yoda who swings his ligthsaber like a baseball bat

VS

Guy with an ugly Padawan pigtail having a decade of force training under Obi-Wan, is able to suvive more than 30 seconds against Dooku and has the greater force potential.

Well...I'd give it to the guy with the ugly Padawan pigtail while asking myself why Dooku didn't cut his head of instead of his arm in AotC.

Luke beat down Vader though, who is supposed to be 80% as powerful as Sidious. Since Dooku and Sidious are about equal, and Anakin and Obi-wan are together about equal, they must be about 50% as powerful as Dooku.
Luke>80%
80%>50%
Luke wins.