Luke vs. Anikin

Started by Tangible God3 pages

Clone Wars-----RETURN of the JEDI.

yes

[/B][/QUOTE]


Luke in ROTJ sucked. He was shit with a saber, his Force powers were raw and untamed, and AOTC Anakin would **** him right up one side and down the other.

He was shit with a saber due to technology and because in the OT GL told the actors to swing their blades like they were baseball bats. He was already able to use Force Choke and pick 3PO and his chair up without moving his hands. What do you mean his Force powers sucked? All AOTC Anakin did was make a few small objects float, having to use his hand to do so. And he jumped from a great height without getting hurt. Big deal.

[QUOTE=5305606]Originally posted by Tangible God
[B]ROTS Vader would be double the overall power of Sidious WITHOUT a suit. WITH the suit, he goes down to 80%.

ROTJ Vader--was not putting out his full effort in his fight with Luke, he may even have took a dive, we know he's better than what he showed. Luke swung like a teeball player and brought down his "untrying" father.

Vader stood back up despite being beaten and having his hand dismembered. Palpatine, after some 23 years of utter loyalty from Vader, and with his whole concentrion focused on kiling Luke, is completely taking off guard (yes, even him, uh huh huh) when Vader PICKS HIM UP...not defeats him combat, but BENCHPRESSES him!

Vader was not stronger than Palpatine, Luke was not stronger than Vader, that being said then the Vader with the potential of DOUBLE Palpatine's power, minus three years, will still kick the shit out of the Luke that "beat" his future mechanical self.

1) With the suit he could get to 100% of Sidious but only ever reached 80%.
2) Vader may not have been trying his hardest to kill Luke but he was certainly trying his hardest not to die, and he failed.
3) Anakin killed the Emperor while he was distracted.

Luke wins

OMFG... for the last goddamn time, darthsith19...

it's not LACK of technology that makes Luke swing his lightsaber like a moron!

It's not!

He's a BARELY TRAINED FORCE USER!

Can you wrap your mind around that instead of insisting it's poor movie making? Hell, by that logic I can say that ESB Luke is a better saber fighter than ANH Obi-Wan because in ANH the technology sucked. Or better yet, I could say that the animals in the Genosian colleseum are deadlier than the rancor in ROTJ because the rancor looked like shit due to movie making limitations.

See how stupid that is? Don't fall for the dark side of idiocy, darthsith19.

I used to think the same way about Vader's mobility.

Originally posted by Deus Ex
See how stupid that is? Don't fall for the dark side of idiocy, darthsith19.

Too late... *shrugs*

There is a fine line between SW and reality...

Originally posted by Deus Ex
I could say that the animals in the Genosian colleseum are deadlier than the rancor in ROTJ because the rancor looked like shit due to movie making limitations...

Wouldn't it be the oppisite? Oh well. Just being a smartass again.

Actually, those animals probably could whup a rancor. It's not the conclusion I have a problem with concerning it... it's the way it's reached. Hence, my point.

I know, but the way you reached it was backwards from what you wanted. What you should of said is that the rancor would win because they didn't have the technology to show that it was deadlier than the animals in the Geonosian arena.