Marvel Hierarchy revised as of December 2005

Originally posted by Sir Whirlysplat
I will GS

Again an opinion which differs from yours is diregarded and dealt with by an insult. I should have taken the higher ground long ago. You only have opinion.

Please don't keep apologising as if your trying to make out your view are cannon they are not. Like most you have to say on this matter it's merely an insult imo.

Your views are flawed (in my opinion) and not cannon (in my opinion)

and its the (in my opinion) which makes the difference in my opinion.

All of this is irrelevant waffle in light of the fact that:

Posted for all to see there are several scans from different titles, by different writers saying exactly Phoenix is both "the Big Bang" "the energies of creation", "the life force of the universe incarnate", that phoenix touches all that lives, that it is "the sum and substance of all that lives" and that a universe without Phoenix is one "wherein lies not the smallest potential for life". They are statements from the comics they are not my interpretation interpret them in another way and post your thoughts here. Simple as. Im betting you cant my friend. 🙂

Im sorry mate but youve lost on this one. Direct on panel statements on a debated point are conclusive. Your argument is that the statements werent featured in the bio. That is irrelevant when the statements arent contradicted in the bio at all and do you really expect all statements made on a character to be featured in a bio? Puh lease Whirly thats a ridiculous notion and i expect better from you. How very disappointing.

But continue if u must. Its quite clear thats its very much game over. 🙁

No opinion here, just quoted statements, so why do you keep saying its my interpretation. Ohhh unless youre complimenting me. Yes youre quite correct my opinion matches the quoted statements exactly. Im glad youve come around.

Cool. 😎

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
All of this is irrelevant waffle in light of the fact that:

Why because you said so? Again its only your opinion like everything else, it's not canon its extrapolation from conflicting writing, and your ideas don't fit the handbook very well.

No ones come round you have an opinion but it's not canon it's extrapolation.

Stop trying to put words in peoples mouths.

No ones lost anything.

I feel sorry for you, you can't accept that you still have proven nothing, you didn't about the K word, which you didn't even know how to spell, you didn't on zero point - both ludicrous extrapolation and you haven't on this thread where you try and argue something different to the thread. (comprehension)

The difference between you and Demi or I, is we add "I think", which is really the problem I have with your efforts.

Originally posted by Sir Whirlysplat
Why because you said so? Again its only your opinion like everything else, it's not canon its extrapolation from conflicting writing, and your ideas don't fit the handbook very well.

No ones come round you have an opinion but it's not canon it's extrapolation.

Stop trying to put words in peoples mouths.

No ones lost anything.

I feel sorry for you, you can't accept that you still have proven nothing, you didn't about the K word, which you didn't even know how to spell, you didn't on zero point - both ludicrous extrapolation and you haven't on this thread where you try and argue something different to the thread. (comprehension)

The difference between you and Demi or I, is we add "I think", which is really the problem I have with your efforts.

No Whirly the reason your last post is irrelevant and why this one follows in that tradition is because i have quoted from the comics directly. They are the very words of the comic so it is not my opinion. None of the statements which are to be found in various titles, by various writers are contradicted in the handbook therefore they remain canon. Deal with it. This farce is hysterical. 😂

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
No Whirly the reason your last post is irrelevant and why this one follows in that tradition is because i have quoted from the comics directly.

The point of a handbook is to make sense of conflicting ideas from writers, you still don't get it. Your interpretations are not canon. again you disregard anything that questions "your" opinion and it is just "your" opinion. None of your ideas are canon and you have not been answering the threads initial point, so in that sense in my opinon all your posts in this thread are irrelevant.

Keep the faith 🙂

Stay Whirly 🤘

This thread had so much promise, and you two destroyed it with pointless bickering.

Please stop.