Obi-Wan(ROTS) And Anakin(ROTS) Vs Mace Windu(ROTS)

Originally posted by Sorgo
He is right. As much as we hate Anakin's sorry ass, he was growing incredibly powerful during ROTS and may have been as powerful as Mace.

I don't hate Anakin's sorry ass. He is on par with them in saber ability. But he isn't equal to any of the big four (Yoda, Sidious, Mace, Dooku). He is a level 9, but is not superior to either four. Mace would best Anakin, I'm certain of it.

Originally posted by Escape81
I don't hate Anakin's sorry ass. He is on par with them in saber ability. But he isn't equal to any of the big four (Yoda, Sidious, Mace, Dooku). He is a level 9, but is not superior to either four. Mace would best Anakin, I'm certain of it.

Mmmm.... I don't know about that anymore.

Originally posted by exanda kane
They were not some of the greatest Jedi of the PT era - unless you count the top fifteen - and he is an awesome dueler, even if he looks retarted when prodding the thing about.

And he used a Force Jump to leap towards then, otherwise he's way past Olympic qualifying distance for the long jump. And Sidious could never beat Anakin easy. Yet again I hope this is merely hyperbole on your behalf. You do however, seem to be dismissing both Anakin and Obi-Wan. Why? They were both the greatest war hero's of the Republic during the Clone Wars. Obi-Wan was nicknamed The Negotiator for his firm principles of choosing diplomacy over violence. But when need be, he could fight. I would not be able to psuh Sidious back like Mace, but he would be able to hold his ground. Did you ever expect Obi-Wan to panhandle Grievous that easily?
Anakin ends the Clone Wars as a duelist rivalling Mace and Yoda, aswell as Obi-Wan, with much more potential coming from him.

And I count Mace, Obi-Wan and Anakin as some of the only Jedi to be able to withstand Sidious' initial attack. Bearing in mind that had Sidious not have had to dispose of those Jedi beforehand, he probably would have lobbed Mace out of a window.

Are you high?

Originally posted by Escape81
I don't hate Anakin's sorry ass. He is on par with them in saber ability. But he isn't equal to any of the big four (Yoda, Sidious, Mace, Dooku). He is a level 9, but is not superior to either four. Mace would best Anakin, I'm certain of it.

Im a not. It would be an incredibly good fight, and if Anakin tapped into the Dark Side, he could possibly crap the hell out of Mace, as he did with Dooku.

And I think it was meant that the general opinion of anakin is that hes an annoying shit.

Originally posted by Sorgo
Mmmm.... I don't know about that anymore.

Anakin has, again, progressed to be a level 9. Gillard has confirmed that the difference between level 8 and 9 is raw aggression and the usage of one's environment, because battles between level 9s are so damn close. Anakin is strong and quick, but is reckless. He is on par with them, but I doubt he's their equals.

Originally posted by exanda kane
Im a not. It would be an incredibly good fight, and if Anakin tapped into the Dark Side, he could possibly crap the hell out of Mace, as he did with Dooku.

And I think it was meant that the general opinion of anakin is that hes an annoying shit.

No. Anakin, in my eyes, is not annoying. He's undeniably clever, and his potential blows Yoda and Sidious out of the water. But he is simply not as experienced, and Mace edges as close to the Dark Side as Anakin does. And forgive me, but the fight between Count Dooku and Anakin lasted a long time, even with Anakin having support.

No. He'd never own Dooku, Sidious, Mace, or Yoda.

Exanda sidious can manehandle GG as well.
Best PT jedi in my opinion
yoda
mace
obi
anakin
Depa
luminara
Cin
vos
bulq
Kit

One of them is in my top ten the other would, yes, be in 11-15.
You can look retarted but if you get a good end result...
I am not dismissing them. I just belive that in this fight they will get lose badly. You are in fact overestimating the duo. yea they are warheros but against a power force user they are chump. You have lost, just like lots of people here, a lot of respect in my eyes.

Originally posted by Escape81
No. Anakin, in my eyes, is not annoying. He's undeniably clever, and his potential blows Yoda and Sidious out of the water. But he is simply not as experienced, and Mace edges as close to the Dark Side as Anakin does. And forgive me, but the fight between Count Dooku and Anakin lasted a long time, even with Anakin having support.

No. He'd never own Dooku, Sidious, Mace, or Yoda.

He would 'own' all of those in a few years time if he hadn't got his limbs cut off in a STUPID attempt to slash at Obi-Wan's perfectly trimmed beard. And I've already said that Anakin lacks experience.

And Anakin is exceedingly annoying, it seems its his divine ability to annoy the hell out of me and a concept called acting. But Mace does not feed off the Dark Side in the way Anakin does.

And the Dooku/Anakin fight went amazingly quickly, I mean in the cinema my phone fell out of my pocket, went to pick it up, came back up and Wohoa! Where did Count Dooku go? And the fight never even got going until Obi-Wan was out of the picture, when Anakin stared to get a little 'red-eyed' as it were.

Originally posted by Darth Avis
Exanda sidious can manehandle GG as well.
Best PT jedi in my opinion
yoda
mace
obi
anakin
Depa
luminara
Cin
vos
bulq
Kit

One of them is in my top ten the other would, yes, be in 11-15.
You can look retarted but if you get a good end result...
I am not dismissing them. I just belive that in this fight they will get lose badly. You are in fact overestimating the duo. yea they are warheros but against a power force user they are chump. You have lost, just like lots of people here, a lot of respect in my eyes.

Well Mate. No love lost from me. I havnt got a clue who you are anyway.

And GG needs to be shoved away somewhere with Maul and all the other junk in the 'Worse Villains Ever' box to be frank.

I believe you have placed Mace on a pedastel. He is a great Jedi etc. but he is extremely over rated (although much of it is deserved it must be said.) Whereas the Chosen One is dismissed and his mentor and quite possibly the Wisest Jedi in the whole saga is also dismissed.

Mace is extremely overrated. Of course most likely because he defeated Sidious.

News Flash: Just because he beat Sidious doesn't mean he can rape anyone! HELLO?

But it does mean he can beat alot of people and if you read shatterpoint he destroyed to gunships with a few gernades and his blade. he is very powerful and i don't even like him that much.

But he is far too overrated! Anakin was supposedly at his level and Kenobi defeated Anakin yet Mace would waste the two of them? I don't see Mace living through this.

Anakin is no where near his level!

Originally posted by Darth Avis
Anakin is no where near his level!

You're funny.

Anakin is Mace's level if not higher.

Remember who loped Mace's hand off? Suprise or not, Anakin still participated in Mace's death and he probably would have been able to contend with him.

Originally posted by Sorgo
You're funny.

Anakin is Mace's level if not higher.

Remember who loped Mace's hand off? Suprise or not, Anakin still participated in Mace's death and he probably would have been able to contend with him.

That is some of the worst reasoning I have ever seen. By that same token, who cut off Dooku's head? It doesn't matter if it was the Count possibly not giving it his all, so he probably would've been able to contend with Dooku. He is on the Count's level, if not higher.

Originally posted by Sorgo
You're funny.

Anakin is Mace's level if not higher.

Remember who loped Mace's hand off? Suprise or not, Anakin still participated in Mace's death and he probably would have been able to contend with him.

So if a youngling accidently chops off Yoda's head, is he just as strong as Yoda.

that youngling will grow up to be the greatest jedi ever...

One battle alone will not determine the superior force. Was America superior to Britain when they won the Battle of Bunker Hill? No. Britain still was the most powerful nation in the world, and won various other battles - though they lost the war.

what does that have to do with this?

Originally posted by Darth Avis
what does that have to do with this?

Point being that many are comparing singular battles as evidence of solid superiority. I am merely saying that that's not always true.