Obi-Wan(ROTS) And Anakin(ROTS) Vs Mace Windu(ROTS)

.....................
this thread is... well let's just say Mace WIN-du's! ha ha ha ha ha... ah.... (breaks off and stares at all potsers)

Originally posted by The Creator
Are you high?

I was at lunch today.

Originally posted by Escape81
Point being that many are comparing singular battles as evidence of solid superiority. I am merely saying that that's not always true.

Which is exactly why comparing Mace and Sidious with Obi-Wan versus Anakin is not fair.

But it is the only thing we have. We have to use it!

No it isnt. Both of those fights were different. If they were in the same place, with the same factors involved then we could.

Who was more powerful Maul or Obi- Wan?
Maul.
But one fatal accident costed him dearly.
So we can't judge it on one battle like Escape 81 says.

Is this the first time I've ever agreed with Sorgo?

Anyway, Avis, Mace can't be no where near his level, they are both level nine's, they have to be at least relatively close in power! Anakin managed to beat Dooku. He sliced off Mace's arm. He beat Cin, Whie and Bene at the same time. I'd give it to Mace, as GL says Mace and Yoda are the only one's strong enough to compete with Sidious, but it's close.

Both Obi-Wan and Anakin at the same time would beat Mace. Both of them are near Mace's level as it stands; with both of them fighting together they would win.

weird, that Mace=dooku and Dooku pwned the duo right.

We can't judge like 1 beats 2, 2 beats 3, so therefore 3 is the worst.

Originally posted by Darth Avis
weird, that Mace=dooku and Dooku pwned the duo right.

Well Dooku lost didn't he? 😛

And how do you know that Mace would defeate Dooku. Dooku is both the superior swordsman and force user, more experience and a user of the Dark Side. I would say he stands a very good chance and would most likley win.

yes but they are VERY close in power. My arguement in dooku vs mace is dooku wins but he is barly a better swordsman, not a better force user by that much, and the darkside gave him lightning. Big whoop. so still they are very close. And we all saw how much stronger dooku is than obi wan, who is equal to anakin.

Why do people keep bringing up 'zOMG!! anikin chopedd WINdu's arm of!11!!'? He trusted him. Mace wouldn't expect Anakin to pull something like that. by your logic, Darth Vader would wreck Palpatine because he throws him down a reactor shaft, Luke Skywalker would own the Death Star in one-on-one combat, and Han Solo would beat the crap out of a Sith Lord.

well DUH. Han can pwn Marka Ragnos so easy. ❌ you are so naive.

I don't get this, who really cares?

Originally posted by Darth Avis
yes but they are VERY close in power. My arguement in dooku vs mace is dooku wins but he is barly a better swordsman, not a better force user by that much, and the darkside gave him lightning. Big whoop. so still they are very close. And we all saw how much stronger dooku is than obi wan, who is equal to anakin.

Agreed.

almost anyway. 😆

why ya laughing?

It was just that I agreed on most points but not all. Donno, just seemd to fit, I was not mocking you. Sorry for putting it the wrong way.

Originally posted by Escape81
That is some of the worst reasoning I have ever seen. By that same token, who cut off Dooku's head? It doesn't matter if it was the Count possibly not giving it his all, so he probably would've been able to contend with Dooku. He is on the Count's level, if not higher.

It's funny how you bring Dooku into this when he has nothing to do with this. Isn't that hilarious? Maybe I should switch my favorite character so you will stop posting irrelevant smack onto this thread.

Originally posted by darthsith19
Is this the first time I've ever agreed with Sorgo?

Anyway, Avis, Mace can't be no where near his level, they are both level nine's, they have to be at least relatively close in power! Anakin managed to beat Dooku. He sliced off Mace's arm. He beat Cin, Whie and Bene at the same time. I'd give it to Mace, as GL says Mace and Yoda are the only one's strong enough to compete with Sidious, but it's close.

Mace and Yoda are the only ones strong enough to compete with Sidious? Okay. It says the only people that are able to compete/defeat Mace are Dooku and Yoda. But do I go by that? No.

Dooku and Mace would stalemate. Bottom line. We honestly have no proof that Mace would defeat Dooku and Dooku would defeat Mace.