Originally posted by kingkman
Revan kills Vader and Malak kills Maul before Nihilus can kill Sion and so Sion, Revan and Malak kill Nihilus (Revan and Sion would have been able to take this without Malak anyway).
Uninlightened Revan was a lot weaker, didn't know most force powers, so I'd have to say Revan and Vader may kill eachother, or just mortally wound eachother. Also when I fought Nihilus, he was crazy weak (beat him in 5 turns), while sion was extrememy hard to beat.
I'd say:
Revan and Vader tie
Malak kills Maul (if a pathetic jedi padawan can kill him, so can a blue freak with no jaw)
Sion kills Nihilus
In which case, team Sith wins
but maybe it'd be:
Revan kills Maul
Malak gets killed by Nihilus
Sion gets killed by Vader
In which case, Nihilus and Vader team up on revan, and team Empire wins.
Or maybe:
Revan gets kills Nihilus
Sion kills Maul
Malak and Vader tie
It all depends on how they match up. Is it a battle royal, or tag-team?
Team Revan takes this, fairly easily.
Malak beats Maul. He is a far superior swordsman, and Maul hasn't exactly displayed the greatest force aptitude.
Revan takes Vader. Vader is a crippled cyborg with severe organ trouble, and while he's still powerful in his own right he doesn't even compare to Revan.
Nihilus owns Sion, even more so considering Sion isn't indestructible in this fight. We've all seen the cut content where Nihilus throws Sion around like a rag doll, that about sums this up. There is a lot more to Nihilus than force eating, and I think he's underrated as a swordsman. Whereas without being indestructible, Sion offers very little.
So it comes down to Malak and Revan against Nihilus, and it doesn't take a genius to work that one out. Revan and Malak take Nihilus down without to much trouble, and the former master and apprentice stand tall.
Yes, vader IS a crippled cyborg, but Revan is a guy who lost his memory, all knowledge of the force, and the lightsaber forms. Yes, yes, somehow he knows all that stuff. But if he knows it, why do i have to level up 17 times??
Malak obviously pwns maul in a fight, but what if he was fighting vader? they're both wierd-lookin and crippled. Sorta.
What woulda happened if Revan fought Nihilus, Malak fights Vader, and Sion on Maul?
There actually is no basis for that. Full potential Anakin according to Lucas is only 60% more powerful than Sidious, meaning Revan's team still wins.
Sion would still take Nihilus, Revan would take Maul, and Malak would be able to fight Anakin off for a very long time until Sion and Revan come help and Anakin goes down.