Originally posted by six6sixWe don't know anything about clone Maul, so we can't draw any reasonable conclusions about his skill relative to TPM Maul. Ergo, your comparison was meaningless.
What makes clone Maul better then the real deal?
And are you saying that ROTS Anakin is stronger then Vader?He's easily a more dangerous swordsman.
Originally posted by Eminence
We don't know anything about clone Maul, so we can't draw any reasonable conclusions about his skill relative to TPM Maul. Ergo, your comparison was meaningless.
Not necessarily. If he's a "clone" he should have all the skills of the real Maul, if not weaker. Like all the clones of Jango, none was shown to exceeed him.
Originally posted by six6six...? Cloning replicates characteristics dependent on genetics. Skills aren't genetic.
Not necessarily. If he's a "clone" he should have all the skills of the real Maul, if not weaker.
Like all the clones of Jango, none was shown to exceeed him.They're soldiers, he's a Mandalorian bounty hunter.
Maybe if Maul had lived, he'd grow strong enough to kill Tyranus. Maul was still an apprentice when he took on a Jedi+apprentice at the same time and ended up killing Qui-Gon, who was one of the best with a lightsaber. Dooku had done the same to Anakin & OB1, yes, but again, Tyranus had already been a master for sometime. So to answer the thread, IMO, as we seen them, Dooku FTW, but if Maul had lived, I think he'd eventually surpass Dooku.
Originally posted by six6six
Maybe if Maul had lived, he'd grow strong enough to kill Tyranus. Maul was still an apprentice when he took on a Jedi+apprentice at the same time and ended up killing Qui-Gon, who was one of the best with a lightsaber. Dooku had done the same to Anakin & OB1, yes, but again, Tyranus had already been a master for sometime. So to answer the thread, IMO, as we seen them, Dooku FTW, but if Maul had lived, I think he'd eventually surpass Dooku.
Maul was a "warrior in his prime" according to TPM novel. So He culdnt have improved in that respect.. Although he could have vastly improved his mastery of the force..