Marv from Sin City VS. The Punisher

Originally posted by Etrigan
Ha, no.

Punisher without prep stands NO chance against Batman.

But we're talking about Marv, not Batman.

yeah dude your the same guy who thinks that wolverine can beat dr doom your very biased with your fav characters, batman with prep could take out the jla i dont think punisher could.

Originally posted by Mider
yeah dude your the same guy who thinks that wolverine can beat dr doom your very biased with your fav characters, batman with prep could take out the jla i dont think punisher could.

anyone who thinks that punisher can beat batman even with prep is overestimating punisher, if punisher dont got a rocket launcher on him or nothing lke that he aint winning

PUnisher can cap bats in the head end of story...

you wish it was that easy you really do ever read when ra's al ghoul used batmans computer info on the JLA he nearly beat all of them punisher couldnt do that.

If he knew what ra's did...what batman knew...than it is possible...

we'll never know

so you really think marv beats punisher?

if its there first meeting then yes

I think that this fight would be a good one. However, I see punisher taking the vast majority after a protracted battle. I say this because I see no advantage that marv has over Frank. Someone posted all of the advantages punisher has over marv , saying that the punisher wins in every area excluding (arguably) durability. I would say that Frank wins in durability too, after visiting the punisher respect thread I have become convinced that Frank has meta-durability. Marv may be tough, but Frank's tougher. Meaning that Frank wins because he has Marv beat in every factor affecting this fight.

Originally posted by The King of All
I think that this fight would be a good one. However, I see punisher taking the vast majority after a protracted battle. I say this because I see no advantage that marv has over Frank. Someone posted all of the advantages punisher has over marv , saying that the punisher wins in every area excluding (arguably) durability. I would say that Frank wins in durability too, after visiting the punisher respect thread I have become convinced that Frank has meta-durability. Marv may be tough, but Frank's tougher. Meaning that Frank wins because he has Marv beat in every factor affecting this fight.

Yeah, the man is hardcore. Awesome respect thread, any one who doubts Frank should go there.

so if you hit punisher in the head and shoot him with out him wearing armer plus electricute him and put him up against a cayote he would servive almost unscaved or at least not giving a care?

I believe that he would. Though certainly not unscathed, he's taken worse before and still managed to prevail. I don't see why this time would be any different.

Originally posted by jgiant
'how this thread has been done a million times' (fyi this is the third time) and how punisher would 'kick marvs ass' .

Originally posted by Mider
batman with prep could take out the jla i dont think punisher could.

thats your opinion if he hates all villians so much and so badly that he wishes to kill every one of them why isnt he going after doom or juggs or anyone like that.

Originally posted by brainchild81
Punisher with as much prep as Batman had against the JLA = JLA R.I.P. Can anyone explain what Marv can do to stop Pun from busting a couple caps in his head?

Nothing. Absolutely nothing. Which is the point of my post. I'm pretty sure Marv could beat Punisher h2h, if he caught him off guard.... but Marv couldn't do anything if Punisher just blasted his brains out.

But Batman could easily beat Punisher with prep. Punisher is much more brawns than brain (although he is quite smart, he's no Batman.) Batman has brawn written all over him, and probably has brain in neon lights underneath his mask.

Batman would have trouble fighting Frank with no prep, but with prep he takes him.

Originally posted by brainchild81
Punisher with as much prep as Batman had against the JLA = JLA R.I.P. Can anyone explain what Marv can do to stop Pun from busting a couple caps in his head?

Well he could i don't know.....DODGE.

Punishers damn 'own villains' aura isn't on people. Marv is not going to stand their with a target on his forehead .

Oh yes and lets all really believe j-giant who's punisher-ed up to his eyeballs , the guy who believes that with prep frank can kill THE DAMN JUSTICE LEAGUE ......