Marv from Sin City VS. The Punisher

Started by sexyking7 pages

Originally posted by grey fox
Well he could i don't know.....DODGE.

Punishers damn 'own villains' aura isn't on people. Marv is not going to stand their with a target on his forehead .

Oh yes and lets all really believe j-giant who's punisher-ed up to his eyeballs , the guy who believes that with prep frank can kill THE DAMN JUSTICE LEAGUE ......

😂 some people just dont like to admit their favourite characters can lose

Originally posted by grey fox
Well he could i don't know.....DODGE.

Marv couldn't dodge bullets, he's probably stand there and take em.

Batman is very adept as that, though.

You don't have to belive certain poster just the logic that presenst itself. I mean how much tougher is Marv than the Russian? Or Bushwhaker?
Anyone that can be killed by a bullet is fair game for Frank.

it was never stated that he could die from bullets though, in sin city did he take any in the head?

He did have lots of face wounds, many likely from gunshots
But at one point he said
"They should have shot me in the head, and enough times to make sure."

Originally posted by Mider
it was never stated that he could die from bullets though, in sin city did he take any in the head?

One. Wendy hit him with a grazing shot in the head. Knocked him out, but didn't kill him.

as i said on the last thread, both marv and punisher are being underestimated. marv's h2h defeat of a fully-armed SWAT team is as impressive as anything punisher aught do, and that was just part of a very long day for marv. which reminds me: people forget about marv's injuries in Sin City; it was all within a couple days. and at the end he was still full of fire.

and marv isn't a slouch with the gun, nor with agility. punisher has him beat in those categories, especially of course with the gun. marv is alot stronger than punisher, though, and yes, he is tougher/more durable. they're pretty similar in philosophy too.

i give marv an edge because unlike punisher, he has several ways to win. if punisher runs out of ammo before he can get a headshot (maybe even two), then he loses 8/10 (punisher is severely underrated h2h).

all in all, Marv 4-6/10.

Originally posted by grey fox
Well he could i don't know.....DODGE.
Yeah. It's not like Punisher's an expert shot that's shot smaller targets that could move much faster than Marv could ever dream of🙄

Originally posted by grey fox
Punishers damn 'own villains' aura isn't on people. Marv is not going to stand their with a target on his forehead .
He doesn't have to. Marv's better @ taking bullets than he is dodging them. Marv's been capped by shooters with a fraction of the skill Frank's got. I like Marv alot, but he's not immune to "bullet poisoning". If bullets can kill you and you're not great a dodging them, you've got no business fighting Frank. Frank will light Marv up like a Christmas tree.

Originally posted by grey fox
Oh yes and lets all really believe j-giant who's punisher-ed up to his eyeballs , the guy who believes that with prep frank can kill THE DAMN JUSTICE LEAGUE ......
I do think J-giant is prone to lean towards Frank more often than not, but here, he's 100% right. Frank is ruthless and great @ ending lives. If Batman can beat the JL w/adequate prep, I don't see why Frank couldn't kill them. Maybe you just don't like Frank.
Originally posted by Warmonger
You don't have to belive certain poster just the logic that presenst itself. I mean how much tougher is Marv than the Russian? Or Bushwhaker?
Anyone that can be killed by a bullet is fair game for Frank.
Good post

I sure as hell like Frank, he's awesome. But he's not as good as Batman. Couldn't take out the JLA, I don't reckon.

Originally posted by Mider
anyone who thinks that punisher can beat batman even with prep is overestimating punisher, if punisher dont got a rocket launcher on him or nothing lke that he aint winning

Oh oh blasphemy. Somebody actually believes Batman can be beaten by somebody below Skyfather level !

Let's crucify the sinner !!

Originally posted by Etrigan
I sure as hell like Frank, he's awesome. But he's not as good as Batman. Couldn't take out the JLA, I don't reckon.

If Punisher has the same information about the JLA members... why not ? Frank is not as intelligent as Batman, but definitely as cunning as Batman.

The only way Frank would ever be able to get such information is to join the JLA, which is highly unlikely, considering his killing attitude.

Punisher wins end of story...

I think the Punisher would easily win.

So what is it like 6 people think frank can win while like two think marv would...grey fox and black adam just hate punisher, they are on a mission to prove that he is just a human with guns...

Originally posted by sexyking
😂 some people just dont like to admit their favourite characters can lose
I admit he loses sometimes...but the majority of the time the people he is put up against he can beat...like marv...

One bullet directly to the head would put an end to Marv, and if the Punisher can shoot the web-slingers off of spider-man while he is in mid-air, and then proceed to shoot spidey himself, then I don't think that he would have too much shooting Marv.

And even if it was h2h, I wouldn't rule out the punisher. He has fought an abundance of characters such as Marv; the russian, that merc who's neck he snapped...the list goes on.

Yeah, and when Marv fights a guy with some decent fighting skills (Kevin), Marv bites the dust.

Marv is just a tough and cool brawler (with some skill).

isnt punisher just some guy with a few guns, i mean in that punisher kills the universe crap he defeated juggernaut witha nuclear warhead which is bull and apocalypse yeah right, apocalypse has taken a black bolt scream and laughed it off, while juggs laughs off a hit from thors hammer and the full power of dazzler as well as a full blown god force blast that could destroy the celestial dome and probably even destroy adimantium, and adimantiaum itself can servive a nuclear blast has wolverine ever been able to hurt juggs?

Originally posted by Mider
isnt punisher just some guy with a few guns, i mean in that punisher kills the universe crap he defeated juggernaut witha nuclear warhead which is bull and apocalypse yeah right, apocalypse has taken a black bolt scream and laughed it off, while juggs laughs off a hit from thors hammer and the full power of dazzler as well as a full blown god force blast that could destroy the celestial dome and probably even destroy adimantium, and adimantiaum itself can servive a nuclear blast has wolverine ever been able to hurt juggs?
THat was bull i know...but punisher is not some guy with a few guns that is for sure...