Thrawn vs Revan

RRRRRREEEEEVVVVVAAAAANNNNN!!!!!

Originally posted by Fierce Deity
RRRRRREEEEEVVVVVAAAAANNNNN!!!!!

Thrawn has a superior fleet. Without the Star Forge Revan loses.

Is everyone going to ignore the fact that trying to judge Revan's tactical skill is impossible?

Or that the KotOR era ships are puny compared to ISDs?

Originally posted by Swirly Girl
Is everyone going to ignore the fact that trying to judge Revan's tactical skill is impossible?

Or that the KotOR era ships are puny compared to ISDs?

True,Traya,but Revan made the best out of what he had,but regardless,I'd say Thrawn.

Ok, he wouldn't have as many ships without the Star Forge. And the ships the build up Revan's fleet are puny compared to ISDs.

Originally posted by Razielim
When was Revan decimating the Republic fleet? He couldn't even think of attacking the core worlds (source: sith and republic soldiers on manaan) even with the unlimited army. Revan was a threat, as was Malak. That's why the Jedi had to capture/kill him.

His Empire was putting up a good fight with the Republic, but was not decimating them.

I'm a little late and this has probably already been brought up, but Revan didn't attack the core worlds because his goal wasn't to destroy the Republic. He wanted to keep it intact. -_-;

And we know his intentions now? News to me.

What I saw was Revan waging war on the Republic, battling Republic fleets and conquering systems.

What? Did you even play KotOR II? G0-T0 makes it pretty apparent that Revan didn't want to annihalate the Republic.

The entire point of Revan's war was to keep the Republic strong enough to withstand an external excursion from the remnants of the ancient sith. He tended to leave certain key planets intact in his strategies.

I'll talk to him when I boot up my game in the morning, but I don't remember him mentioning Revan trying to strengthen the Republic. I remember some vague quotes about him trying to protect the galaxy, nothing with a Republic . . .

You might be right, I didn't spend much time talking to him anyways