If the DE team wins at all, it'll be by a hair. In a prolonged duel, Luke's going down against Malak, so unless Palpatine can whip out a Force storm before he's set upon by Revan, we're going to have another crispy Skywalker. In fact, I see Revan and Malak taking this.
The two have been on countless fronts together, during the Mandalorian Wars and their skirmishes with the Republic. They'll have far more collusion than Luke and Sidious, and that should give them the edge they need here. Hell, even if the renegades were strangers, they'd lose simply because Malak would slaughter Luke before Sidious could manage to take out Revan - if he even can, in a duel.
Originally posted by tdtd
What makes you think Malak could take down DE Luke? Both of them have been shown fighting each other at insane speeds. Neither Malak nor Revan could contend with them in a saber duel..
? What does saber speeds have to do with anything. In E3 Sidious uses the Ataru style of fighting relying on high speeds and acrobatics to defeat an opponent. Meanwhile Windu uses Vaapad, a lightsaber style that relies more on precision and a firm foundation to defeat its enemies. Although Sidious was doing some fancy leaps and moving at faster speeds, Mace fought with precision and was able to finally bring Sids down. Same deal with Revan and Malak.
Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
really? what's BS about it?
Nothing as far as I know.
The DE team takes this. Not by a ton, but they take a solid victory. DE Sidious is a large amount stronger then Revan, and DE Luke could give Malak a very hard time, perhaps even defeat him. In anycase, Sidious will defeat Revan before either Malak or Luke can kill the other. DE Sidious and Luke then proceed to pwn Malak.
Originally posted by tdtd
You still haven't proved why Malak and Revan would be superior to the DE duo, especially since Sidious and Revan are likely on par, and Luke more powerful than Malak.
And you haven't proved that the DE duo is better than the KotOR duo.
See, the problem here? You can't adopt one opinion and then ask for resounding conclusive evidence for the contrary. In events like these, all you need is reasonable doubt.