Darth Revan and Darth Malak vs ROTS Palpatine and ROTS Yoda

Originally posted by Jonathan Mark
TDTD have you been taking lessons from IKC?

No because he's not always right, so why would you bring him up? I read and observe..

By the by: Posted on the last page

Originally posted by tdtd
No because he's not always right, so why would you bring him up? I read and observe..

No I mean how you both are rude.

Lightsnake, all of your arguments are easily refutable.

Then refute them. Provide PROOF Simus was DlotS and the greatest of all Sith wizards/alchemists...provide proof Xendor was a Sith Lord when he lives 18,000 years BEFORE the Empire was formed...please refute the official chronology

www.swcomics.com Google all of this crap, you can find canon sources that Xendor was the first, that the first great schism was 25k years before the empire, and Simus was the DLOTS before Ragnos, but he was the greatest Alchemist during his time, not the greatest ever...

Xendor was not a Dark Lord of the Sith. He was a Dark Jedi, but the title "Dark Lord of Sith" hadn't been conceived until Ajunta Pall landed on Korriban.

I know he was the first Dark Jedi. Leland Chee said the Legions of Lettow weren't Sith....and when is Simus described as a great alchemist?

Google it lightsnake I am not about to look all of this up for you, you are a big boy, you can find it. And that's what I said, Xendor was the FIRST DJ.

Yes, and he wasn't a Sith Lord, which was what this was about.

You make claims. Back them up. I have

No you haven't. You're using outdated material and biased/illogical opinions.

What outdated material?! a source from 2001, a source from 1997 and a source from late 2005?! And recent quotes from the bigwigs at LFL?

Good lord, you act as if your material is more canon than anything else. Show me where it says Palpatine is the most powerful, and where.

New Essential Chronology, page 84

http://img384.imageshack.us/my.php?image=proof9gs.jpg

Lightsnake said: Ajunta Pall's assumed to be the first DLotS now

tdtd said: And again you're wrong, Xendor was the first dark jedi.

I think it was just a misunderstanding.

And this is C-Canon how?

....because C-canon includes everything after G-canon, including guides and books and RPG sourcebooks?

Show me where this is approved or even looked at by GL or LucasArts/LucasFilms, etc...

....The Essential Chronology? Dan Wallace is a writer at LFL?
http://www.starwars.com/eu/lit/ref/f20051025/index.html

LOL. Next thing you're going to do is say the SW databank is canon and Sidious pwned Yoda right? Lol