Freedon Nadd & Darth Malak vs. Yoda & NJO Luke

Force battle only. Who wins?

Nadd dies. He dies hard

I'd give it to NJO Luke alone more often than not, adding Yoda is an overkill.

NJO Luke would easily defeat him alone. Same with Yoda.

There's no more often than not, Nadd is woefully outclassed

How is he woefully outclassed? Nadd is among the best of the best, even as a spirit. He would curbstomp Yoda into little pieces, luckily Luke is there.

Nadd is... cant find a word to describe the outcome.

Ok how about adding Malak to the Nadd's team?

Originally posted by tdtd
Nadd is among the best of the best.

And Luke or Yoda aren't.

Still. Yoda>Malak

And no, Yoda is nowhere near the level of Nadd.

Malak without the star forge never really impressed me too much. Luke and Yoda still easily win.

...what the hell? Curbstomp Yoda? When was Nadd one of the 'best of the best?' Let me sum up his entire fall:
Masters: You gotta fail once
Nadd: But I'm so cool and brave'n strong and I want to be a Jedi! *Kills Matta Tremayne in a mishap* AAAAH! Gotta run away!
Naga Sadow: *Cough cough* I'm awake...and real old...my hip...it hurts...
Nadd: teach me!
Naga: Ok *Later* Actually, no. no, not gonna give you the real good stuff
Nadd: What?! I haaaaaate yoooou!
Naga:...why do I keep making mistakes with young, whiny humans? *dies*
Nadd: haha, Onderon! *Does force powers*
Primitive natives: Oh, thank you for your help, great on!
Nadd: Heh heh.
Primitive Native group 2: Boooo, we hate you! *Years later*
Nadd: *Killed in uprising* This sucks!

Nadd is outclassed by Yoda completely, Yoda described as the 'strongest foe the darkness had ever known'...and that outclasses Nadd who is nothing compared to what else the darkness can offer

Since when is Nadd one of the best? Since being an ancient Sith Lord/Dark Jedi, since learning from Naga Sadow, since driving Kun completely down the dark side, since force pushing Vodo as a spirit.. Yes, he is right behind the ancient sith.

Force pushing Vodo as a spirit?

...Naga refused to teach him the real secrets, and driving Kun down the dark side? why does that mean ANYTHING? He lashed out at Vodo on KORRIBAN, too...seriously, man...try again.

Uh Naga refused to teach him everything.. Driving Kun down the dark side means everything. He lashed out at Vodo as a spirit. You're an idiot lightsnake.

Yes, I've read it. It's where my info comes from

Obviously not, read it again.

*Reads* Nothing about force pushing Vodo...just the once instance when Nadd lashes out at him on Korriban...yeah, nothing else Nadd ever does to show he's powerful

Youre right, because all spirits have been able to do something to living users.. Oh wait, just the ancient sith, Kun, and Nadd. And he lashes out at VODO as a spirit, what do you not understand here? That's a testament to his power.