Qui-Gon vs. Cin Drallig

Who Wins this battle takes place in the Theed Palace

Qui Gon easily. Cin died in less that 2 seconds to Anakin.

Uh huh. From what we saw, Cin tied up Anakin for much longer than 10 seconds. And the fight wasn't even resolved.

Cin could beat Grievous. I say he takes Jinn.

Done before.

And, Cin wins. Qui-Gon was killed by Darth Maul, and Qui-Gon, throughout the fight, had the help of Obi-Wan. And, I'm sure Maul had to exert more energy, and still managed to kill off Qui-Gon.

Either way, just because Cin "died to Anakin" doesn't mean he sucks, and that applies for Jinn as well, but Cin would win.

I need Some Evidence on both Sides Before i vote

I used to think that Qui-Gon would win but now I think Cin would win. According to Dooku, Cin > Grievous, and this is Grievous before getting injured by Mace. I doubt Qui-Gon could take that form of Grievous, who put up an okay fight agains Mace in LOE. I'm not even sure whether Qui-Gon could beat ROTS Grievous.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=356115&highlight=Cin+Drallig+vs+QuiGon+Jinn

Then Right Now I'll Vote for Cin

Originally posted by darthsith19
I used to think that Qui-Gon would win but now I think Cin would win. According to Dooku, Cin > Grievous, and this is Grievous before getting injured by Mace. I doubt Qui-Gon could take that form of Grievous, who put up an okay fight agains Mace in LOE. I'm not even sure whether Qui-Gon could beat ROTS Grievous.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=356115&highlight=Cin+Drallig+vs+QuiGon+Jinn

If you're actually going by LoE, then Grievous doesn't actually suffer any crippling wounds at the hands of Mace Windu.

I think Qui-Gon would win. He was an exceptionally good Jedi and would have been on the Council if he was less...(in need of a word) Cin was taken down by Anakin in seconds. We don't really know a lot about him, but he doesn't seem like that great of a Jedi to me.

Although Qui-gon is easily one of my favorite SW characters, I have to say that Cin takes this. He was head combat instructor over 10,000 Jedi and, as was previously stated, believed by Dooku to be better then GG.

BTW, this thread has been done before.

I say Qui-Gon Jinn. Like PurpleSaber said, he would have ben on the Council if he wasn't so defiant and rebellious. That would have to mean that he was exceptionally strong both with the force and with the sword. Cin Drallig was the Battlemaster of the PT era, but that by no means automatically makes him the greatest swordsman. For example; say there are two guys playing an online game. One guy has one game and is very good at it, while the other guy has several online games. Does that make the second guy, who has more games, a better online player. No. For all we know, he could suck at it, but that's not the point. The point is, just because Cin knows more fighting styles, dosen't mean he's a better deulist than Qui-Gon Jinn, who would have been appointed on the council if it wasn't for his way of thinking.

Cin was taken down by Anakin in seconds.

Point being? Is Qui-Gon the same person as Anakin? No.

And Qui-Gon was taken down by Maul, who had to have been at the least a little tired from being attacked by two Jedi, and who is not on par with ROTS Anakin. Either way, it really doesn't matter.

Like PurpleSaber said, he would have ben on the Council if he wasn't so defiant and rebellious.

I'm overcome with joy for Qui-Gon. Cin was said to be able to best (or something to that effect) most of the Council members. Being on the Council doesn't make you uber. See: Coleman Trebor.

Qui-Gon Jinn, who would have been appointed on the council if it wasn't for his way of thinking.

And, Cin Drallig, who was said to rival Council members IIRC.

I believe Qui-gon was said by one of the saber instructors to be the best swordsman he'd seen in four hundred years

That was from the TPM novel, and was supposedly stated by his Master: which is retconned by the fact that his master was Count Dooku.

Wasn't it just the saber instructor? Same thing as Yoda 'instructing' Obi-wan mayhaps?

Nope, it was his master.

Qui Gon would have probably become better then Cin had he survived until ROTS, but he didn't so I don't see him being able to take Cin Drallig down.

Originally posted by BLAK FOX
Qui Gon would have probably become better then Cin had he survived until ROTS, but he didn't so I don't see him being able to take Cin Drallig down.

I do Qui-gon was said to Rival Mace so that would mean. Mace is far superior to cin.

Mace>>Cin

Qui-Gon>Cin

While I defenently see Qui-Gon winning this, I highly doubt he could rival Windu. Where did you hear that, anyways?

your probably right but Qui-Gon was 60 at the Time of TPM so maybe he could have.