Qui-Gon vs. Cin Drallig

Started by Darth Sexiest3 pages

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
Decent fight? It was a joke.

According to a report made by Imperial Moff "Wessel" who served the Emperor, it was indicated that Lord Vader cut down Dralling following a [b]short exchange of Light Saber strikes.

Dralling posed no threat to Vader and his skills were joke when he faced a real man who had proven himself before.

I don't call this a decent fight. [/B]

All reports made about Drallig's death in Imperial record were falsified and exagerated on purpose.

Didn't know that, huh? 🙄

Yes, but we se him fighting Anakin, while he is choking a padawan and later being kiled by Anakin in the novel.

Cin never actually fought against Grievous. We know from ROTS that Grievous was no push-over and was giving a good fight to Obi-Wan (who I think is better then Cin).

Grievous didn't do that good against Kenobi. The LOE quote leads many people to believe that Cin > EU Grievous.
And those 4 knights are not among big names like Anakin, Obi-Wan, Mace and Yoda in PT period in terms of skills and capabilities. When Grievous met one of the best in true sense (namely Obi-Wan), it was game over for him.

Still, taking out 4 Jedi who were strong enough to be given the task of protecting Palpatine is something that QGJ couldn't do. And yeah, he lsot to Kenobi, so what, Kenobi > Maul.
TPM Qui-Gon was no joke either. Obi-Wan said this about Qui-Gon: "Qui-Gon Jinn was perhaps the greatest Jedi alive, a commanding presence at Council, a strong and brave warrior who refused to be intimidated by even the most daunting challenge, and a good and kind man."

That was Kenobi, obviously he'd be biased towards his own master. Plus it only means that QGJ is strong, it doesn't mean that Jedi like Cin, Yoda and Mace couldn't take him.
He was indeed defeated by Darth Maul but Maul was no joke as well as Sidious indicated in TPM about his skills by saying "You have been well trained, my young apprentice. They will be no match for you." Sidious indeed was confident about Maul's capabilities.

Yes, Maul was good, but not better than EU Grievous, who a lot of ppl think Cin could take due to that one LOE quote (myself included).

One thing though, unless you mean ROTS OB1, then Maul>OB1, the novel states as much. That was one of those "lucky" moments that OB1 seemed so quick to disregard in ANH.

But of course i would put ROTS OB1 over Maul, but certainly not TPM OB1.