Darth Traya, Darth Nihilus, and Sion vers ROTS Sidious, Count Dooku, and ROTS Anakin

Originally posted by ESB Vader
not being offending, i was reading some of the earlier post about this thread and i find some of them giving really stupid comments, b4 i post i read and i research and i do not babble nonsense,

Lol. Well, when you have an argument between Lightsnake and Sexy, it usually goes like that, hah.

well back to the fight, what r ur opinions on sion vs anakin?

i havnt researched much about sion but if the battle took place on malachor then i think sion has the advantage, anakin is cocky frm what i see in the movies and he just rushes into battle without planning.
unless he knows what to say to beak sions spirit and chop him down, i say sion might win

Sion is virtually indestructible I guess, and somehow I don't see Anakin breaking his will, so that he can win. Now, if Sion didn't have his "immortality", Anakin would probably win. Anakin has demonstrated the ability to think before he acts ("This time we take him together...", "...I was about to say that"😉, but when there's a lot of other factors in the way, he tends to just rush in. For example, against Obi-Wan he wasn't thinking clearly at all, and was just hellbent on killing Kenobi. Against Asajj, he wanted revenge. I don't see what factors would be getting in the way of him and Sion.

Personally, I don't see how Sion (without being immortal) could beat Anakin. Anakin has shown us greater Force abilities, and he's more than likely the better duelist. Sion, in the KOTOR 2 cut content, was pwned by Nihilus just using the Force.

Originally posted by Advent
Lol. Well, when you have an argument between Lightsnake and Sexy, it usually goes like that, hah.

Sion is virtually indestructible I guess, and somehow I don't see Anakin breaking his will, so that he can win. Now, if Sion didn't have his "immortality", Anakin would probably win. Anakin has demonstrated the ability to think before he acts ("This time we take him together...", "...I was about to say that"😉, but when there's a lot of other factors in the way, he tends to just rush in. For example, against Obi-Wan he wasn't thinking clearly at all, and was just hellbent on killing Kenobi. Against Asajj, he wanted revenge. I don't see what factors would be getting in the way of him and Sion.

Personally, I don't see how Sion (without being immortal) could beat Anakin. Anakin has shown us greater Force abilities, and he's more than likely the better duelist. Sion, in the KOTOR 2 cut content, was pwned by Nihilus just using the Force.

I think it's somewhat unfair to somehow assert that Sion is weak just because Nihilus wasted him with a gigantic force push. Indeed, we've seen Nihilus slam Kreia into a wall without much effort.

The difference between Sion and Nihilus' techniques is that Nihilus' was given to him, and thus without it we don't really know exactly how powerful he is, while Sion learnt and earned his. I mean through willpower alone he was able to keep his body together and even cheat death. This basically made him physically invincible. That is probably one of the most awesome abilities in the whole saga. So while we don't know much about him, I think it's pretty safe to say that he was a total badass.

Originally posted by Sith'ari
The difference between Sion and Nihilus' techniques is that Nihilus' was given to him, and thus without it we don't really know exactly how powerful he is, while Sion learnt and earned his. I mean through willpower alone he was able to keep his body together and even cheat death. This basically made him physically invincible. That is probably one of the most awesome abilities in the whole saga. So while we don't know much about him, I think it's pretty safe to say that he was a total badass.

And you know this, how? We don't know anything much about how Nihilus and Sion gained their techniques.

We find out in KotOR.

nihilus' team owns them .