Darth Traya, Darth Nihilus, and Sion vers ROTS Sidious, Count Dooku, and ROTS Anakin

Go edit it then..

Erm...yes they do, pal. It's Star Wars and all of it has to go through Lucasfilm. Lucas himself does not, but his company and editors certainly do

Wrong. EU does not. It is fact that if EU contradicts Lucas then it's wrong, but EU does NOT have to go through Lucas. Now stop with your crap, this argument is over.. At least wait til someone else posts here to spew your nonsense.

Can we cut out this contemptible argument please?

And just to make things clear- in absolutely no way, shape or form does wikipedia come close to being an acceptable source. Any one of us could post up there that Nihilus is a giant turnip being with fourteen mushroom heads tomorrow. It does not matter if it is the only source- it isn't a source at all. And if you say it is the same as another source, then use that souce, not wiki. Wiki will never, ever be a source- not in academia, and not here.

Ok fair enough Ush, yet Wikipedia doesn't contradict the game, nor vice versa. So if you want technicalities, I will use the game as a source, therefore its still valid. And you also missed my point where Wiki only supports the game, or vice versa.

Hey, Ush, while you're here...does the EU have to go through LFL or doesn't it?

Yea Ush, and since youre a mod please explain Nihilus to all of us, since we would love to hear it, especially lightsnake.

Depends what you mean by 'go through'. I mean, if it has no connection with LFL then it is not actually EU, it would be fan stuff.

so what do you define as go through?

I mean that, all EU must be reviewed and edited by Lucas's company, and approved.

Also, I sent you a PM...I did what you recommended

nihilus wins on his own.

Yay for idiocy

🙂

The thing is, either of the darths do.

This is overkill...

The PT gang is in for an ass whoopin.

Originally posted by PurpleSaber
The PT gang is in for an ass whoopin.

Yup

1. Traya vs. Sidious.

Personally? I think that Traya could theoretically just wave her hand and kill him with her instakill (DE Sidious is a different story). And if not, she could give him a hell of a fight until someone comes in to change the tide.

2. Nihilius vs. Dooku.

Dooku > Nihilius in combat ability, but Nihilius has his nifty Force drain. So Dooku goes down, one way or another. If the drain itself doesn't kill him, Nihilius will then strip him of the Force and cut Dooku down.

3. Sion vs. Anakin

Another case of "the PT combatant possesses better skills, but lacks that one nifty ability". That one nifty ability - invincibility. Sion and Anakin would fight for a long time, simply because - though Sion can't die - I see Anakin as his superior. Thus, Anakin will eventually be overwhelmed or Nihilius comes over and helps spank his ass.

Then, if Sidious isn't dead, they all WTFpwn him.

Traya vs. Sidious:

Traya can lift three lightsabers, so what? Sidious can lift three senate pods.

Nihilus vs. Dooku:

Is Nihilus' force eat-thing instantaneous? If not, then, couldn't Dooku just punk him in lightsaber combat?

Sion vs. Anakin:

Anakin beats him up until he can get help.