What is so great about AOTC???

MAx Rebo...

ROTJ has the best opening sequence of all films though, and the scenes with Vader, Luke and the Emperor are awesome... THat kinda redeems the ewoks and the Jabba Palace scenes to me. AOTC has no such redeeming thread.

Originally posted by Alliance
Its sad to associate the two.... AOTC is on and off my favorite SW...ROTJ is permenantly rock bottom.

nice sig by the way... 🙂

Well, they both have at least a solid half hour of amazing scenes that are vital to the entire saga, and lots of filler in the middle.

I meant more that each episode is considered by (most) fans as the inferior of that trilogy.

Personally, I don't have a "lesser" of the PT, they all rule.

And thanks, I like the sig too. If your'e interested in one I know a guy who knows a guy....

@ Queeq
The scenes of Anakin on Tattooine meeting the Lars, loosing his mother, and commiting his first act of dark side murder are equal (in terms of importance to the saga as a whole) to the Vader, Luke, Palps scenes in ROTJ.

ROTJ has the best space battle, ATOC has the best land battle at the end.

The opening of ROTJ is better, though I still like Obi and Ani "In Da Club". It sort of redeems the slow start to ATOC. Also worth mention is the first scene of Anakin and Palps together. Short scene, but very good setup.

Ha. The BoG scenes don't cut ti for you?

I love the Vader, Luke, Emperor scenes...but ROTJ is beyond slavagable...the digital horrors at Jabba's palace, the ewoks, and the unfair treatment of the empire ruin it for me.

All the emotional scenes in AOTC suck, including the ones one Tatooine. Now if we'd actually SEE Anakin slaughter the Tusken... then, maybe....

Originally posted by Alliance
Ha. The BoG scenes don't cut ti for you?

I love the Vader, Luke, Emperor scenes...but ROTJ is beyond slavagable...the digital horrors at Jabba's palace, the ewoks, and the unfair treatment of the empire ruin it for me.

ROTJ is at the bottom of my OT list, but AOTC is at the bottom of my entire list, simply because of Hayden and Natalie, and their dialogue.

Which is a good reason. So where does ROTJ rate in your whole list?

Originally posted by Tangible God
I thought we were all beyond using graphics as excuses?

ROTJ is at the bottom of my OT list, but AOTC is at the bottom of my entire list, simply because of Hayden and Natalie, and their dialogue.

Its not the graphics...i said "DIGITAL"...its that stupid 80's rock out song.

Which is the new edition, what about the original then, when all that is out?

I dont mind it then. Honestly...I think the new editions are worth it though...sorry.

I like all the matte fixes, all the technical improvements, even the new Tatooine shots in ANH. It kinda needed that. What I don't like is all the color timing they did, thus ruining the original and groundbreaking look of Star Wars.

And royally screwing up Luke's saber in ANH on the Falcon (making it off-green) and Vader's in ROTJ. (making it pink) 😘

INdeed... those suck big time.

Indeedy.

And I still wonder why... They can make the most fantastic things and even fan pics have better lightsabres than the redone versions of the 2004 DVD's..

I demand to know why is was changed from blue to green. surely it would not be difficult to make it a more defined blue. even lucas made a point to make sure the saber obi-wan pick up at the end of RoTS is indeed the one from ANH. why then change the colour to green. dont tell me the colour changes thru time?

It was cyan, not green. But in that colour scheme of the shots it looks green...

Well, either way they better fix that shit for the box set next year.

I don't care if the color scheme isn't "correct".

Vader is now a much more whiny pussie type....

GL doesn't need to cut his balls off completely by giving him a pink lightsaber.

lol

I think his balls were torched already in III.

Actually, he lost them to Lando in a bet. tongue_ss

ohhh....Lando.