What is so great about AOTC???

Started by queeq11 pages
queeq Chaos

I agree though... they should have gotten those sabres right...

Alliance Enforcer of the Republic

Its jsut so you can buy the boxed set next year. Then the boxed+edited prequels the next year, then the re-re-edited the next year, then the boxed re-re-edited the next year, then the whole set will be release when Lucas dies.

queeq Chaos

And then they'll release the ultimate-edition-the-way-Lucas-had-originally-intended.

Alliance Enforcer of the Republic

And then 7 more versiona with 45 alternate endings and no extras.

queeq Chaos

And then a box set with originals and half the extra's we want.

Then another box with the other half minus one or two things... etc. etc..

Alliance Enforcer of the Republic

we're having this conversation in like 4 threads.

queeq Chaos

Great huh?

Alliance Enforcer of the Republic

Supurb.

queeq Chaos

We can even do it in five or six.

Alliance Enforcer of the Republic

Lets go.

queeq Chaos

Hehehehe

Alliance Enforcer of the Republic

hehehe

queeq Chaos

This has gotten funny...

overlord OD'd

Originally posted by sithsaber408
Well, they both have at least a solid half hour of amazing scenes that are vital to the entire saga, and lots of filler in the middle.

I meant more that each episode is considered by (most) fans as the inferior of that trilogy.

Personally, I don't have a "lesser" of the PT, they all rule.

And thanks, I like the sig too. If your'e interested in one I know a guy who knows a guy....

[b]@ Queeq
The scenes of Anakin on Tattooine meeting the Lars, loosing his mother, and commiting his first act of dark side murder are equal (in terms of importance to the saga as a whole) to the Vader, Luke, Palps scenes in ROTJ.

ROTJ has the best space battle, ATOC has the best land battle at the end.

The opening of ROTJ is better, though I still like Obi and Ani "In Da Club". It sort of redeems the slow start to ATOC. Also worth mention is the first scene of Anakin and Palps together. Short scene, but very good setup. [/B]


Especially meeting Larse was the defining point which made it as emotional as the ending of RotJ, wasn't it? But in all honesty, I can hardly remember anything of the fourth time (in AotC) they went to Tatooine again.
That "best land battle" also didn't really impress me, it was more of playing in the background whereas the battle of Hoth was much more interesting.

queeq Chaos

Yup... the PT looks great, but emotionally it's all a bit dead.

Alliance Enforcer of the Republic

There's emotions like cuirosity and excitement...se samoe ones present in the OT.

OB1-adobe Senior Member

I think the movie starts great and ends great.

The middle ehhhh

Alliance Enforcer of the Republic

I thought the Kamino sequences were well done. Naboo....meh.

queeq Chaos
Originally posted by Alliance
There's emotions like cuirosity and excitement...se samoe ones present in the OT.

I beg to differ.

Alliance Enforcer of the Republic

Ok. You can have an opinon too.