ROTJ Palpatine vs. ANH Obi-Wan & ESB Yoda

My apologies escape, I'll respond to your post when I'm ready..

I'm laughing at the thought of Kenobi and Yoda fighting Palpatine with lightsabers at this point in their lives. 😂

lol, yes i realised that, you chose each character at their oldest, even the winner has to be careful, might break a hip or somethink >_>

Actually, they would probably be pretty good, well, at least Kenobi; Yoda and Palps would be a bit rusty, but, still good, most likely.

yeah i mean liek lolcopter

Originally posted by Escape81
No, he did not. The novel stated that both of them were equals. The fight could have gone on longer, but Obi-Wan sacrificed himself to save Luke.

Reading comprehension, you learn it in school.

See Obi-Wan sacraficing himself = voluntarily letting Vader win.

But thanks for the free re-iteration.

Originally posted by Darth Scythe
Reading comprehension, you learn it in school.

See Obi-Wan sacraficing himself = voluntarily letting Vader win.

But thanks for the free re-iteration.

I'd recommend dispensing with your attitude of superiority, arrogance, and sarcasm. Because you're dead wrong. 😉

For you see, the ANH novelization - which is a canon source - stated that they were equals. There are other sources, to which Jollyjim can provide, that shows Obi-Wan as slightly inferior to Obi-Wan.

Novelization & other sources > your opinion.

Edit: Oh, and I wouldn't go around bashing people for "reading comprehension", because you don't even know how to accurately spell. It's *sacrifice*.

You said Obi Wan was inferior to himself, other than the brain fart, you're right.

Originally posted by Escape81
I'd recommend dispensing with your attitude of superiority, arrogance, and sarcasm. Because you're dead wrong. 😉

For you see, the ANH novelization - which is a canon source - stated that they were equals. [B]There are other sources, to which Jollyjim can provide, that shows Obi-Wan as slightly inferior to Obi-Wan.
Novelization & other sources > your opinion.

Edit: Oh, and I wouldn't go around bashing people for "reading comprehension", because you don't even know how to accurately spell. It's *sacrifice*. [/B]

lol@Obi-Wan being inferior to himself.

Read back to my original post. In it I stated Obi-Wan wasn't weak and let Vader beat him basically.

Kenobi wasn't as weak as everyone thinks. Remember he did let Vader VOLUNTARILY beat him on the Death Star. At his age he could have but up a very good fight.

You in turn, did a hybrid agree/disagree reply and repeated my point. You seem confused from my vantage.

Someone please find the part where I said Ben is a chump and Vader pwned him easily because he couldn't fight. If you can't I'd suggest halting your argument because you'd be debating a point I never brought up.

Whoops. Obi-Wan is slightly inferior to Vader.

Obi-Wan couldn't have defeated Vader anyways, as of ANH. Meaning, he would've lost anyway.

I doubt the Jedi could beat Sidios. By ESB Yoda ain't that strong, according to Lucas ANH Kenobi > Yoda. According to the ANH novel Kenobi = ANH Vader so he's 80% of Sidious but by this time Sidious should be much faster than Yoda and stronger with the Force than either Jedi by a fair amount, so I see him winning by killing one of the duo early on in the fight.

Originally posted by darthsith19
I doubt the Jedi could beat Sidios. By ESB Yoda ain't that strong, according to Lucas ANH Kenobi > Yoda. According to the ANH novel Kenobi = ANH Vader so he's 80% of Sidious but by this time Sidious should be much faster than Yoda and stronger with the Force than either Jedi by a fair amount, so I see him winning by killing one of the duo early on in the fight.

Uh no, Lucas said ANH Obiwan was the #1 good guy, and this was before Yoda was created.