Mace Wundu versus Darth Maul and Darth Vader

Setting: The area strong with the dark side in Dagobah. Where Luke had to confront the "phantom" Vader.

EDIT: Mace "Windu" folks. I meant "Windu" 😂

Darth Vader alone would be a match for Windu(mind you he wouldn't beat him), so adding Maul would be too much. Then again, Maul's style requires space so the cohesiveness between the two is going to be shaky considering Vader uses powerful slashes.

Not familiar with Wundu. hmm

theyre not a good team. both of their styles need space. windu would get rid of darth maul, and then vader

Originally posted by Captain REX
Not familiar with Wundu. hmm

Nope, not as familiar as with "Aniken" and "Sideous"....

I belive the two will be to much for him....

The place where Luke confronts Vader is called The Cave of Despair. Vader and Maul would swamp Windu. No pun intended.

Princess Bride anybody?

Well, Maul and Windu would duke it out with Vapaad while Vader would try to choke Mace. Windu would probably kill Darth Maul, but then loses to Vader. Vader himself would give Windu a helluva time with his Djem So.

Um Maul doesn't know Vaapad. And in an all out battle that's probably accurate. Vader would be the superior here in force abilities, but in a saber fight Mace would win in a long hard battle.

Well sources say that Maul is a practicioner of Vapaad, though I am not a 100% sure. Anyway, Mace woudn't win in saber combat. Darth Vader would overcome him.

Neither one of them could handle Mace in a 1 on 1 saber combat. Maul is 100% NOT a practitioner of Vaapad. Maul's style and double saber requires space, and so does Vader and his powerful blows, so they can't coexist.

At the end of ROTS, Sidious tells Yoda, "Darth Vader will be stronger than either of us." While it was a slight exaggeration, it must be true. While Vader was confined in his suit, he became a lot stronger and more powerful in the force, since he was training under Sidious during the time span between ROTS and TNH.

Yes, they won't be working together. Maul and Mace would be fighting with lightsabers while Vader would be using the Force. After Maul dies, Vader would take over and finish Windu.

Oy.. Darth Vader as in potential, as in NOT the robot that Darth Vader became.

Actually, for some reason I believe that robot Vader can beat Windu.

See, we judge Mace Windu due to his saber skills performance in Episode II and in Episode III against Sidious.

Now, if you ever paid attention to the lightsaber fights in teh original movies, they were considerably slower. If the same movies were made today, the battle between Vader and Luke would have been more epic. Due to moviemaking during that period, technology couldn't allow such fights. Therefore, we judge Vader by his saber performance in the original film, which is nothing compared to Windu's. However, if the battle was remade Vader's saber skill would much more impressive and thus we would judge his skill higher.

Now, I have absolutely no clue what i just said, and people might think my judgement is crazy, but this something that has been in mind for a long time cuz many people underestimate Lord Vader.

Originally posted by Master Vos
Actually, for some reason I believe that robot Vader can beat Windu.

See, we judge Mace Windu due to his saber skills performance in Episode II and in Episode III against Sidious.

Now, if you ever paid attention to the lightsaber fights in teh original movies, they were considerably slower. If the same movies were made today, the battle between Vader and Luke would have been more epic. Due to moviemaking during that period, technology couldn't allow such fights. Therefore, we judge Vader by his saber performance in the original film, which is nothing compared to Windu's. However, if the battle was remade Vader's saber skill would much more impressive and thus we would judge his skill higher.

Now, I have absolutely no clue what i just said, and people might think my judgement is crazy, but this something that has been in mind for a long time cuz many people underestimate Lord Vader.

This is a debating forum bro, not an "I think" forum. Robot Vader is absolutely no match for Mace Windu in terms of saber combat. We DO judge Mace by his win over Sidious in ROTS, along with Shatterpoint and CW cartoons. ANd please don't start blaming the 70's fights on choreography, because I can refute that by saying Vader was a robot who lacked agility, and Luke hadn't learned a single light saber form.

No, I am not BLAMING anyone, I am saying that the choreography did have an impact. But perhaps I am wrong. Mace Windu has speed and strength while Vader has the Force and strength. And Luke did practice some form. Under Ben Kenobi, he practiced probably a Soresu variant and under Yoda an Ataru form. Thus, he fought with Djem So, though he wasn't a master at it.

windu would be thrashed, windu could kill maul alone, but i disagree that windu could beat vader on his own, vader was the most powerful jedi as anikin, vader just seems slow because his fights were back when it couldn't be made fast.

This is ROBOT ANAKIN.. Hence the Darth Vader, not ROTS Anakin who WIndu would beat anyways.

I think we all know that man.