seperation between light and dark powers

alright i had this conversation about what should be a dark side power and a light side including the inbetweens, and yea yea i know choke, lightning, plague, screem, are dark and heal, sheld, resistance, are light thats obvious i am talking about things like lightsaber throw weather they should be considered light or dark, personslly i think it should be a dark side power

gun_bandanarifleraygun

Originally posted by Blank force
alright i had this conversation about what should be a dark side power and a light side including the inbetweens, and yea yea i know choke, lightning, plague, screem, are dark and heal, sheld, resistance, are light thats obvious i am talking about things like lightsaber throw weather they should be considered light or dark, personslly i think it should be a dark side power

gun_bandanarifleraygun

i know its simple telekinesis but it is very agressive and agression is not the jedi way

It doesn't have to split a man in half, you know?

sostarwars

Most of those powers you listed are video game powers, and are used only in game, and therefore not canon.

Originally posted by ((The_Anomaly))
Most of those powers you listed are video game powers, and are used only in game, and therefore not canon.

Powers themselves are not of any nature unless they require the Dark Side or Light Side for usage.

For example, throwing your lightsabers with telekinesis could go either way. If you're using the Dark Side, it's a Dark Side power. If not, it's a Light Side power.

Dark Side = using your emotions for power and letting them use you.

Light Side = controlling your emotions and not using them for power and gaining power by understanding and training.

that didnt answer my question but never the less i still think that it should be a dark side power

Originally posted by ((The_Anomaly))
Most of those powers you listed are video game powers, and are used only in game, and therefore not canon.

It depends on the intention behind the action.

doesnt matter what the intention is it still very agresssive

tank

So if I want to just stop a Person with Force Crush, but it accidently kills them, then I wont turn Dark =)

yes because it is an accident

But what if it wasn't, you knew it would kill them, but you wanted to Incapacitate them
bangin

Originally posted by Blank force
yes because it is an accident

and if you knew it was going to kill them then its not a god damn accident

Also as mentioned in novel "Traitor" Jacen learns that there is no dark side of the force if you choose to use a force shield (a generally claimed "light side" power) to prevent air from getting to an enemy, you are choosing to be immoral. The force is simply a tool, you can't call a screwdriver evil just because it is easier to screw nails than a wrench. It is not the force that is evil, simply the force user.

not true and besides the fact nobodies answering my question should saber throw be a dark side power

Originally posted by Blank force
not true and besides the fact nobodies answering my question should saber throw be a dark side power